Talk:Seddie/@comment-24139638-20141217020426/@comment-3180503-20141217025003

^ Part of the problem is that Carly came about so soon after Madisen (almost suspiciously so) and I think Nathan banking on having an automatic Madisen replacement (as in long-term, full-time girlfriend) and Carly just didn't end up being that for him. Gosh, it makes me sad for him just thinking about it. ;/