Talk:Seddie/@comment-5761137-20130930014115/@comment-14284535-20130930162346

I am with Seddiecake on this one. (Recall that I embargo, so I don't ship...)

Point of fact: if he had not at least been considering hooking up with Sam again, why on Earth would he bring up that possibility to her when she called about Carly's mood? This kind of question doesn't come out of nowhere.

Based on that interpretation, I think his response to the Creddie kiss starts as surprising, goes to awkward, and then he gets into it - almost as if his 11 year old self takes over. The best retcon I can come up with is that he's a very hormonally-over-active teenage boy. Carly is his "default crush" and Sam is his "growing up" first love. Then his default crush gets requited after a lot of years. No matter what his other feelings are, that pull to Carly is going to be fairly strong unless he's hooked up with someone else.

Put more succinctly: Freddie needs to grow up out of his first crush.