Talk:Creddie/@comment-3999180-20140107212637/@comment-14284535-20140117163345

You should notice that I am rigidly following my canonicity rules.

@Godlovesusall - I don't care what "facts" BSDS put out for the Creddie kiss - I only go by what I see on the screen. IMHO, that is a romantic kiss - period. So I am with you there. I also assumed that Freddie is smart enough to set up a VPN and router on the iCarly website where Carly, Sam, and Freddie can all webchat privately. (If I can do it, he certainly can.)  I assume they are a couple because of this and are working on developing their relationship, but because I have not seen anything definitive since then, I will grant others their assumptions that they might have fizzled out (e.g., "iSaved Your Life") or decided they don't work as a couple either (similar to "iLove You").

You know what I think of your argument about the phone call. I will leave it at that.

@Cartoonprincess - Now you know why I wanted a canonicity conference. My view is unless Carly appears in the special and she, Sam, and Freddie agree on something, we can not even consider making that officially part of the canon for iCarly the show. However, in the universe that contains iCarly, we can assume it there. Check above for my canonicity rules and my example.

Thus, IMHO, no, you can't consider whatever happens in Sam & Cat to be fully relevant to iCarly unless there is something specifically iCarly or has "enough" characters to be considered canonical.