Talk:IHalfoween/@comment-4914162-20120510195759/@comment-4559766-20120513102440

If I had to rate each season out of ten, it'd probably be:

Season 1: 6/10 (the show started off badly but the quality of this season quickly picked up upon the debut of iNevel)

Season 2: 8/10 (in my opinion, this season was one of the best because of the general feel the show had at this point, along with many, many good episode ideas)

Season 3: 8.5/10 (this season was ever so barely better than Season 2 because of the added romance, plot/character development and the brilliant episode ideas)

Season 4: 6.5/10 (still better than Season 1, just barely, but all in all did not live up to the previous two seasons at all, mostly because it was far too short but also because a lot of the episodes lacked energy such as iGot a Hot Room and iSell Penny Tees, although after iStart a Fanwar, the episode quality was up there with the highlights of Season 3)

Season 5: 5/10 (this is where I think iCarly really began failing, because of the lack of new ideas resulting in multiple special guests to increase ratings and plot rehashes, and most of the episodes were disappointing, with only a couple of good episodes)

Season 6 (so far): 6.5/10 (iApril Fools was hilarious, iGo One Direction was a horrible mess, iOwn a Restaurant was better than anything Season 5 had, iHalfoween failed to impress me despite Nevel returning although Sam had me cracking up the entire time, and I haven't watched the newest episode yet)

I hope Season 6 can impress me on the level Season 2/3 did but I seriously doubt it at this point, although iRescue Carly sounds interesting and I'm looking forward to finally being able to watch iPear Store (iWork For Pear, or whatever else people call it).