User blog comment:TheWheelie24/Why Seddie NOT happening would be weird & illogical now/@comment-1976613-20110331162458

Alright, I'll bite and try my hand at a little argument. Actually, I could counter your whole argument by saying everything you are saying is based solely on speculation. You may appear to have concrete evidence to back up your arguments, but you leave a lot of things out. By the way before I start I am a neutral shipper who thinks at the end of this show no relationships will occur.

First, point you have no idea what Dan is referencing, you said yourself that it could be about iOMG but as you said it's only sort of likely, it could just as likely be about iPWV, a huge iCarly event that most fans will be extremely happy about. I mean it's a full 2 hour movie, what good fan wouldn't be excited about that?

Second that interview was not before December, it was posted on facebook 4 months ago, which would make it in November, and there is no evidence whatsoever in the promo that says FREDDIE chooses between the two, it says SAM is in love.

Your third point has nothing to do with anything, it's just a bad title, moving on.

Fourth: Dan is just creating hype. That's his job.

Fifth: Once again she did say she can't say, and to be honest those winks and nudges could have very well been for comedic effect, or to avoid the question and make her content. Just because she made those motions doesn't make it fact.

Six: once again, just because she was wearing a Seddie shirt and Jennette said she will really like the finale doesn't automatically make the finale Sam/Freddie related, she has to support her show so no matter what pairing shirt that person is wearing she'll say that they'll really like the finale. If she saw someone with an iOMG shirt with Creddie as a background will she tell them that they won't like the finale? Of course not it's bad publicity for her show.

Seven: Again, so? He said it MIGHT change your life, he didn't say "this episode will definitely change your life, no question about it" once again this tells the audience nothing.

Now onto the promos: These promos are absolutely not shipping related. A promo is a mash up of clips from the episode there is no real order and there is no connection between any of them. All the stares could be and most likely are from different scenes just spliced together. Carly's shocked face could be your one point, if once again you knew 100% for sure what that face was resultant from, there are so many possibilities. Yes she could have seen Sam and Freddie kiss, she could just be surprised that Freddie and Sam are having such a deep conversation, she could have seen Sam walk away from Brad, Brad walk away from Sam, a teacher interrupt a moment between Brad and Sam, or Freddie and Sam, she could have said that she loved Carly, or Gibby, or anyone and Carly would have made that face.

And sorry, having Sam date Brad would change iCarly forever, because it would change Sam's character, it's not like she's going to be as aggressive as she usually is if she has someone there to calm her down or make her actually happy, and Dan makes the same effort for most every episode of iCarly, it's his job. So really, you can't say it is illogical for Sam and Freddie NOT to get together until you see the episode, and if they get together, then you can be right. But in the highly more likely event that no relationship turns up, I don't want to hear about a mass of iCarly fans whining to Dan again.