User blog comment:Sockstar1/Creddie fans prepare yourselves for iSeddie/@comment-3569728-20110605223656/@comment-1742110-20110605233011

Yep, Dan does have final say on the episodes. But your point is an interesting one. Just like i don't like how Sam was portrayed in iMeet Fred. I didnt like the way Carly was portrayed in iSYL.

Now i have not done research on what other iCarly episodes the two guys who wrote iSYL did. But maybe you can compare Carly to the Carly in those guys other episodes and sort of compare. Eric Goldberg & Peter Tibbals wrote iSYL. They also wrote the episode "iWont Cancel The Show", "iTwins", "iMust Have Locker 239". And they wrote nothing in the first half of S4.