User blog comment:SeddieKissiOMG/Possible reasons why it could've been Melanie in iOMG/@comment-799379-20110416142903

1. "Seddie fans weren't that excited". What planet have you been on? Seddie fans were jumping up and down screaming after iOMG came out. 2. "Since when is Sam in love? If Sam was in love with Freddie...." Well, since when is Sam in love with Gibby? I can use the same argument against you and have more credibility becuz Sam hangs out with Freddie more. 3. "'Sam' kissed Freddie, she would never do that." What would you do if all your friends encouraged you to make a move? She gave up and went for it. And her saying "Sorry" is a perfectly sound reaction. 4. "Sam is wearing stripes". She only hates stripes on guys. 5. "Melanie is being really nice/Sam is changing, not really her" One name: Brad. Brad gave the perfect opportunity for her to hang out with Freddie. He's a red herring, if you will. 6. Melanie's voice is much higher than Sam's.

Here I just debunked every one of your arguments.