User blog comment:Sockstar1/Creddie Is Canon/@comment-3180503-20121124183516/@comment-2032682-20121125174354

Happiest for me? As in personally. Thanks :)

As for your reply: You in italics.

''I have to ask how you still think Creddie is canon after? the creator himself? implied otherwise. Doesn't that fact automatically trump all other facts?''

Dan can say what he likes. He needs to put his vision, what he 'thinks' happened and show it to me on screen for it to mean anything.

He could have just as easily written "I actually intended for xyz scene to imply that Freddie and Spencer were lovers" or "their plane crashed. No-one survived", or "Sam crashed her bike and she's dead."

In all seriousness, just because Dan says something in a blog doesn't mean it has any inherent meaning for the tv show.

What he wrote on his blog is not in any way, shape or form a fact as it relates to what he produced, wrote and filmed. TV Canon is built up from the show. Not from post-episode 'blogs' written with the intent of pandering to Seddie shippers because he's got 2 new shows to be green-lit, which will make him millions of dollars and keep him in a job for another 2 or 3 or 4 years.

''Sure, Creddie happened in the episode. And to be fair, I suppose from a show standpoint it ended more Creddie than Seddie. But the fact that Dan himself told us not to look too much into the kiss proves that he left the whole thing out in the open and therefore? neither ship is canon.''

Dan needed to show us. By refusing to show us that the kiss meant 'friendship' I will take the shows canon moments over his pandering. I will take that kiss, and compare it to dozens of other relationships on other shows. I will compare it to real life. It was a last minute kiss in the final episode of the show. I will take the knowledge that Carly knows Freddie has a crush on him. That Freddie has that crush on her. That Freddie has always wanted Carly to be his girlfriend, even though he did end up with Sam for a few weeks. Because that's what happened on the show.

So that when Carly stopped Freddie in his tracks, tooks his hand, then romantically kissed him, I can see that it means they will be together. I have a TV show full of moments, we have the combined cultural tropes, cliches if you want, we have dozens of shows that had last minute kissing and we have the cultural norm that last minute kisses are intended to show two characters getting together.

No-one can just wipe that out because Dan decided 10 months later that he didn't want it to look like that.

I watch iCarly, the TV Show.

Not iCarly the TV show/Writers blog.

''You may argue that he simply added that to the blog to pander the Seddie fans and that may be true, but it still doesn't change the fact that he did it. He didn't have to do it.? ''

He needed to do it on the show for it to have meaning.

Without it happening on the tv show, he makes it pointless. Examples:

He could write on his blog that the show is actually set in Chicago.

He could write on his blog that that decide that the name of the show is actually iMiranda.

He could write on his blog that Freddie is actually a girl. And Sam is a guy.

He could write that he never actually meant for iLove You to include Sam and Freddie saying "I Love You". He actually meant them to say "I love Carly".

He could say he actually meant for the ending to be Steven staying in Seattle while Spencer and Carly go to Italy.

He could say he meant Sam's bike to be a monster truck.

What he can't do is change the canon facts of iCarly by writing a blog about it. Even if he was the person who originally wrote the show.

Bottom line, Dan is a huge troll and he screwed with 'both? '''sides in the finale. Please respond, I'd like to hear your thoughts.? :) ''

He trolled Seddie fans badly. It was reprehensible that he had the nerve to bring up Seddie the way he did in the finale. When he KNEW that he was going to end the show by having Creddie kiss.

That was disguisting. If he didn't want Seddie to happen they shouldn't have said a word about getting back together.

He has 'trolled' the Creddiers in the fandom, by trying to muddy the waters.

He also trolled them somewhat by not making it clear on the show.

While I still believe it is perfectly clear in the canon of the show that they kissed and are together (albiet in a long distance relationship), it is disapointing that they did not actually talk about leaving, or their feelings, or Carly coming to terms with them. On screen.

We got the kiss, we got canon and endgame but it's not as good as it should have been.

I hope that answers your questions.