User blog comment:SeddieKissiOMG/Possible reasons why it could've been Melanie in iOMG/@comment-3517755-20110415192148/@comment-3517755-20110415223903

Yes, that's a good point. She's pretty far away with that private school. You're also right on the point with Carly knowing the difference, I don't think she could be fooled by that even if she was in a rush with thinking Sam was in love with Brad. And if it was Melanie, where was Sam? I know there could many explanations for that, but I highly doubt Melanie would go out there, trap Sam in a closet and try and make out with Freddie.