Talk:Creddie/@comment-3425559-20110429185925/@comment-3101374-20110430005258

Both. I have a theory that Carly expressed feelings in iSYL, either because it was the "icing of the cake", or it was a perfect oppurtunity to do so. Then, when Freddie broke up, she was reluctant to express feelings again, cause she didn't want another ruined relationship. So... yeah.