User blog comment:Cartoonprincess/Why Carly is *NOT* Acting OOC in iLMM/@comment-3015402-20110812050226

One question though: just because Dan created the characters, doesn't mean when other writers (who have written for the show since S1) write an episode, its OOC?

I mean, I always feel the characters have more meaning to them and its usually a big (two-parter/shipping) episode when Dan writes them. When other writers do the episode, its usually a one-shot with no continuation.

While iSPT is probably the least favorite episode among this wikia and pretty much all iCarly fans, and its shocking for some of the characters to act that way, I don't really think it would be OOC if it was on the show. I think when they credit a writer, its just the one at the table who happens to pitch the plot.

So, just an agreement to what you said about because its written by the writers, its not OOC. But disagreeing with the OOC of other episodes.