User blog comment:Churchpants/If Sam and Freddie Dated How Would Carly Feel?/@comment-3221718-20101231111324

Yay! The question I've been waiting for!

She would probably laugh at first and say something like "Yeah, right..." She'd be slightly put off, and wonder when it all happened. Then of course she'd get used to it, and defend them no matter what. Here's the talk I always imagine.

(All three are sat down on the couch)

Freddie: Me and Sam are dating.

Carly: (Laughs a little) Yeah, you two on a date! DATING! (Laughs a lot more)

(Freddie and Sam look at each other in an "Oh no" way)

(Carly looks at them and stops laughing. Her voice becomes higher than usual) Carly: You're serious??? WHAT?!? But you two ha- When did this little situation happen?

Sam: (Sheepish) About 2 weeks ago.

Carly: (Deadpan) 2 weeks ago. (Hurt) 2 weeks ago, and you guys didn't tell me?

Sam: (Defensive) We didn't know if we'd work, you know, together! (Sorry) I'm sorry, Carls... (Carly and Sam look at Freddie)

Freddie: What? (Sam elbows Freddie in the ribs) Ow. Oh, yeah! I'm sorry too.

Carly: (She turns her head from side to side, from Freddie to Sam. A huge grin fills up he face) SPENCER!!!!! IT FINALLY HAPPENED!!! SAM AND FREDDIE FINALLY HAPPENED!!!

Spencer: (In the shower) YES!!!!!

And that's how I think she would take it :)