Talk:Seddie/@comment-5129303-20121121064645/@comment-4196911-20121121114711

'Carly has said plain and simple that she doesn't keep things from Freddie. Would it really be likely that she would be keeping her feelings a secret if she liked him?'

Correct, I've been saying that for years. She's not the type of character who hides what she's really thinking. Sam's the opposite, of course - which is why the idea of her being in love with Freddie but totally burying it was plausible.

Not sure how maybe her leaving with Dad would suddenly make feelings come to the surface either - it would simply be her thinking she loved Freddie because of a high-stress, unusually emotional situation, which would be little different in my mind from iSYL which didn't last.