User blog comment:Bolivianbacon/Pinpointing Freddie's Bike Accident/@comment-4184884-20110921013137/@comment-4184884-20110921232804

Sam says "Four months ago...before we started going out". Carly says "Four months ago...before she liked you."

Though maybe that right there is an important delineation to make. Sam says it was before they were dating. Carly just assumes it was before Sam liked him. Sam knew it wasn't so that's why she didn't say that.