Talk:Seddie/@comment-4473095-20110925133253

"When Freddie said I love you he meant I love you, but I’m not in love with you. You don’t tell someone you just broke up with that you love them romantically. If they loved each other romantically, they would never have broken up. They both agreed they don’t work as a couple. Freddie is too ‘normal’. Sam is too ‘abnormal’. They never balanced each other out, instead they pushed each other into acting too differently. They just didn’t work. It was nice to finally see Sam and Freddie admit they do love each other as friends. It was a sweet emotional moment of closure to the pairing by finally pushing their friendship to the same level as Carly and Freddie, and Sam and Carly have. They love each other as friends. Then the kissing? They made out for an hour because it was a convenient time close to midnight, and it was a mutual break up. It’s the kids show equivalent of break up sex. A final physical moment of closure to the emotional closure of the relationship. In iSYL they never kissed for an hour because it wasn’t a ‘mutual’ break up. Freddie broke up with Carly because in his mind he would be taking advantage of misplaced emotion from Carly. It was left open without closure because Freddie didn’t want to break up, and still wanted Carly to be his girlfriend. He kissed Sam because they both knew exactly what their emotions were. They love each other as friends, nothing more, so make the most of the last hour of the relationship before ending it for good. That’s the difference between iSYL and iLove You. Seddie got it’s 5 episode arc, explored the relationship, showed that they don’t work, and gave it closure and a mutual breakup to show that there are no hard feelings and without making Carly the cause of the breakup. The pressure of the lock in and Carly forced Sam into kissing Freddie in iOMG. The pressure of Carly and the intensity of the Seddie fans and the whole mental hospital pushed Freddie into kissing Sam in iLMM. In iDS&F, we were shown that they fight too much, and that dragging Carly into their fights is wrong. In iCTI, we saw them overcome Mrs. Benson. That Freddie wasn’t going to break up with Sam because of his mom, and that Freddie forgave Sam for her actions prior to the arc. In iLove You, they finally spent time together, without interference. Without the pressure of Carly, or the Seddie fans, or Mrs. Benson pushing them to break up. Obviously, that just made them push back. They finally were able to get ‘clean air’. And it showed they don’t work. They are better as friends."

Theory posted on the Creddie page. Saw a Seddier say it sounds like it makes sense. What do you think? I disagree.