Talk:Creddie/@comment-5679407-20121122051557/@comment-2032682-20121122155159

There is a huge difference between someone's feelings existing since before the show starts, to someone who has felt a different way (Freddies crush on Carly), who then suddenly changes their behaviour (liking Sam back) '''during the show. '''

The first doesn't have to be overly explained. Freddie likes Carly, the first conversation Carly and Freddie have is about his crush on her. It's an existing thing.

The second must be explained. Why does Freddie like Sam now? What changed? Something taking place during as story requires development. If you change something without showing why or how it isn't good writing.

Freddie did not fall in love with Sam. He got in a relationship, it didn't work out. It seemed quite clear to me he meant he loved her in a friendship way. If they were both in love with each other what Carly said wouldn't have mattered.

I just feel it was made so obvious based on what happened with end of Seddie relationship and that it was never brought up again (except one very minor mention as a joke) that they aren't in love with each other. For Freddie telling Sam that yes, he has his crush on Carly back during iOAR should be a confirmation on that. If he's in love with Sam, why is he crushing on Carly again?

Creddie's relationship was extremely truncated due to the nature of the episode. iSaved Your Life was only one episode. And half the episode was gone by the time Carly kissed Freddie for the first time to start the relationship. And one scene later Sam was wrecking it.

Seddie had an episode that ended with the kiss, then four entire episodes dedicated to their arc. Seddie had 8x the amount of time together as Creddie did. What we got out of it was that they were cute together, that they transitioned easily into a full relationship and they were hot when kissing ;)

It's sad as Creddiers that we never got more than the end of iSpeed Date and half of iSaved Your Life as Creddie episodes. Even iGoodbye it looks like the Creddie scene happens right towards the end, not leaving much time for Creddie cuteness.