Talk:Seddie/@comment-24856071-20121006015928/@comment-4196911-20121006030041

"Am I the only one who believes Sam was lying in iDate Sam and Freddie when she told Freddie she first started to like him when she pushed him in front of the bike messanger."

No, because we have no idea when that was. It could have been Season 1, it could have been before the show started. We have no idea. Dan wants you to have your own ideas about when it was.

"Carly also later stated in I think iCan't Take It that Sam started liking Freddie 4 months before the arc. I think Sam was lying, since there are MULTIPLE hints from episodes AND Dan that show that Sam has liked Freddie for MUCH longer than just 4 months. Maybe Sam lied because she didn't want to tell Carly that she liked Freddie while Carly and Freddie were dating."

Again, Carly doesn't know when Sam started liking Freddie. All Carly knows was that it was REVEALED that she liked him in iOMG. Other than that, we have no idea what Sam and Carly did or didn't discuss or what was or wasn't said. IMO, Carly just made a mistake and said "before she started liking you" when she really meant "before we all knew she liked you." Sam could have liked Freddie as early as sixth-grade, and just been in denial about it. I personally think there's evidence for that.