Talk:Creddie/@comment-2032682-20121125132342

The Italian Guy FallacyOkay, for some reason certain shippers have latched onto the scene where Carly decides to leave as proof against Creddie. So note, this isn't 'ship warring' against Seddie, it's defending Creddie.

For whatever reason, they are using a line said by Steven Shay, Carly’s father, as a reason to tear Creddie down and to portray Carly in a bad way.

The scene: When Carly is thinking about leaving, she asks Spencer who tells her she should go, and just as she’s about to say yes, Steven pipes up with a line about Italian guys.

Carly says “I’m going to Italy” right after. Which she was going to do anyway, you could see it in her eyes the moment Spencer said to go.

Carly never said a word about Italian guys.

There was around 4 hours between the end of that scene, and when she had to leave.

They have enough time to do a invent and setup for a webshow, for Carly to start packing, and for her to have a heart-to-heart talk with Spencer.

All before she actually goes up into the studio to Freddie.

You can think about a lot of things in four hours.

Maybe her speech on the webshow made her rethink her and Freddie’s relationship.

Maybe her talk with Spencer made her rethink her relationship with Freddie, and what Freddie had done for her in the same way that Spencer had done his things for her.

Maybe she packed up a picture of his and her feelings came rushing back, or her heart tugged at her and yelled at her to go kiss him. To not leave without doing what she knew in her heart she wanted to.

And that is enough to change it all.

So please, stop acting like Carly is being ‘mean’, or doesn’t care about Freddie, or that she’s already planning her dates with Italian guys instead of starting a long-distance relationship with Freddie until she comes back or he goes to her, or that Creddie was in any way ‘hurt’ because her father told her teenage daughter about how there are guys in Italy.

It’s not the big deal you think it is.

Carly kissed Freddie. That’s way more important for our ship than a line her father said about Italian guys.