Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20150716150146

Based on what I can piece together from the thread below (my Twitter is @Sweetsass1 if anyone wants to fill in any missing details), here's what I think went down:

From 2008 to mid-2010, Jennette and Nathan were pretty much inseparable; both due to Nick putting them together constantly and them developing a genuine kinship. Nathan appeared to be very notably smitten with Jennette; whereas Jennette seemed the slightest bit less interested (this was during her innocent period so maybe the thought didn't even cross her mind).

If I'm not mistaken, mid-2010 is when Debra's cancer came back. On top of that, Nathan met Madisen and all of a sudden his whole world revolved around her. This had to be the point where Jennette realized she had feelings for Nathan and she probably felt very jealous and threatened by Madisen (and vice-versa). I believe the timing  and vulnerability of both these situations caused Jennette to pull back and  avoid  Nathan.

Onto the Australian KCA's--Nick, unaware of Jathan's blossoming issues, once again paired them up to co-host. Naturally, they hit it off again and possibly discussed a relationship.

As you guys know, I don't really buy into the theory that Jathan ever dated. For one thing, after Nathan met Madisen, all bets seemed to be off when it came to other women. Nathan was ***obsessed*** with Madisen and I don't buy that he would cheat on her or that he would choose THAT moment to kindle a relationship with Jennette (why wouldn't he have tried it back in 2008 when they were at their closest and when he was a notorious flirt?)

Anyway, I have two theories regarding Jennette crying and cancelling the UStream. Either...

A.) as previously stated, Jennette and Nathan rekindled their closeness at the Aussie KCA's and Jennette's feelings were stronger than ever. BUT Nathan was still with Madisen and he ended up calling her later that night or something--leaving Jennette feeling devastated and heartbroken over the reality of Nadisen. Or...

B.) they tried things very briefly at the KCA's but Nathan ultimately picked Madisen for the obvious religious reasons.

From that point forward, Jennette lost most of her innocence and became very bitter/awkward about any mention of Jathan or Seddie. Additionally, she cut Nathan completely out and bonded with Miranda (the only other one left). This caused Nathan to centralize on Madisen even more and she became his whole world--plus, the Twitter incident and stuff.

Nathan did try to keep in touch with Jennette and maintain a friendship but, by then, it was too late to fix things. The whole fiasco was apparently so terrible and so traumatic that, even when Nadisen broke up, Jennette chose to befriend Madisen over Nathan (most likely due to being similarly heartbroken).

This is my working theory...who fucking knows at this point? xP