Talk:Seddie/@comment-10909858-20131102223130/@comment-14284535-20131103201157

Please everyone remember - "iEmbargo" = "I don't ship" and I don't believe in "meant to be." I believe that the only reasonable way for Creddie or Seddie to happen AND BE LIFE LONG is if they date other people, maybe even marry and are widowed or divorced, and then hook up again after many years as different people who happened to have grown in the same direction. A data mining of the 2000 census figures released in 2008 showed that only 10% of all high school romances end in marriage; over 2/3 of those end in divorce within the first 5 years and almost 90% of them end in divorce.

This is from Godluvsusall a few days ago. I am taking a break at work to respond.

> I don't really think so iEmbargo.

> That was used as an "argument" about how iCarly would end as well. The outcome was different.

> And for "Creddie to end", Freddie should be presented as really unstable "mentally"(among other things) which would ruin his character as well as the continuity. So, I have no reason to be afraid.

First, I am ignoring whatever nonsense Dan Schneider said about the kiss. What I saw made the ending of "iCarly" 100% Creddie to me. Having said that, do you realise that if Freddie decides that a long distance relationship is not for him (hardly an unreasonable attitude), then you are arguing that mentally unstable?

Second, I also take him asking Sam if she is asking to go back out with him 100% seriously as well. Because FREDDIE brought it up, I assume that FREDDIE had been thinking about asking her back out; no more, no less. Therefore, his reaction to the Creddie kiss without mentioning his discussion with Sam already ruined his character. Period. It looks like you are arguing that this is OK because it made "iCarly" end Creddie. If so, I expect that because Sam still talks with Carly, then Carly dumped his butt so fast once she found out about him asking Sam out that it would make her head spin.

"Sam & Cat" is VERY DIFFERENT from "iCarly" - a sizable chunk, if not a majority of the fans are Seddiers. If he portrays Creddie as set in stone, the show is toast. IMHO, the only reason he ended "iCarly" Creddie was because he knew that Creddiers wouldn't watch "Sam & Cat" if there were even a hint of Seddie that could not be rationalised away.