Talk:Seddie/@comment-24139638-20140816225612/@comment-3180503-20140817031513

Do you remember what they were up to at the time? I'm surprised I didn't catch on to it considering how closely I've been watching them for years. Was it in the Fall? I have to say, though, I reckon they were not anywhere NEAR as close as they were back in their heyday in 2008/2009. I believe if they ever did go out (which I still doubt they ever did), it would have had to be during that time. Come on, their chemistry was absolutely dynamite at that time. Now, I don't deny that they probably had feelings for each other, but I think it may have been the whole religion thing that ultimately kept Nathan from going for it. Then, when he met ultra-Conservative Christian Madisen, he got struck by some acursed arrow. Jathan's chemistry always struck me as that formed by sexual/romantic tension. That's why I think Jennette initially became so distant from Nathan as soon as Madisen entered the picture.

It makes me wonder if Jennette knew all along that Madisen was no good for Nathan and she befriended her just to get her to break up with him and then...nahhhhh. I wish. ;_;

No, but really. There's a huge gap of logic here; Jennette obviously wasn't always close to Madisen. In fact, for a while, she was the main wedge between her and Nathan. How is it that Jennette managed to get close to her and not consequently rekindle her friendship with Nathan? Is there still some kind of ill-will over him not choosing her to begin with? If it has to do with the reasons I suspect, then I don't blame her. xP