User blog comment:StraightACarlaay/Who's the prettiest character?/@comment-3984115-20110615185037

Overall I'd say Carly is slighty ahead of Sam. But Carly and Melanie are just equally pretty.

How comes? Melanie and Sam are both played by Jennette?

The difference for me is just her facial expression. Sam looks serious, pissed or angry most times, while Melanie looks friendly and smiles. That's the only reason why I rate Melanie higher than Sam.