Talk:Seddie/@comment-3503512-20120523022842/@comment-4196911-20120523035243

Carly doesn't have any "feelings" to "put aside." That's the point. Creddiers want this to be true, but there's no evidence for it.

Carly could have moved on Freddie at any time between iSYL and iOMG. That was a LONG time. She did nothing. Freddie was totally available, nothing stood in Carly's way. Carly's not the type of character who ever hides her romantic feelings, and with Freddie she would have absolutely zero reason to do so.

Instead she ignored Freddie and chases every other boy in the universe. She specifically denies anything with him in Fanwar (including "love"), says he's not "hot" in iLMM, and she then works like the Dickens to hook him up with Sam.

For crying out loud, the only reasonable thing to think is that she just doesn't love him, and Dan wants that made clear.

I'm continually shocked by people who wilfully ignore when Dan specifically wants you to notice Sam being jealous, yet turn around and completely invent scenarios where they think Carly is jealous. It's like an upside-down universe.

Carly doesn't behave like someone who is jealous, and if she actually was jealous, sje could have fixed it at any time by simply speaking up and making Freddie her boyfriend.

She never did it, and Dan never put in any scene, dialouge or reaction shot where he wanted the audience to think she was going to do it. Heck, she wasn't even thinking about it.

Does anyone really believe Dan is going to make Carly do something to (her real BFF) Sam that Tori was totally unwilling to do to Jade? Pfft.