Talk:Seddie/@comment-5998251-20150410132605/@comment-25746087-20150410173626

I agree with @Princess (as usual) that even if Dan's plan was "Creddie all the way and throw away the Seddie plot" like everyone believes, with what was given, Jennette and Nathan did a piss-poor job with it, letting their personal problems get in the way, much more so with Jennette. Even though Nathan was (probably still is) on the "I hate Seddie" train, from the interviews he did after iOMG, he seemed much more willing to act professional about it, and give what he could to Seddie, even though he didn't like it, and I personally think that showed on screen. Jennette however, made her disdain perfectly clear, and that was completely unprofessional. And @Moden, I don't think Madisen was on set during the Seddie arc, she started coming on set after that time, around when iOpen A Restaurant was airing.

I do agree @Epic, that to a general viewer it could definitely look like Seddie was just a fling, with how the arc was written and acted. But as @Princess said, fans have seen growth from the years, and had hoped to see that growth show through in a relationship, but it didn't, whether it be because Dan didn't want it to or because Jennette and Nathan didn't want it to (or both).

Personally, I think Jennette said Seddie is a "fling" and she bashes Seddie so much because she associates Seddie with Jathan; and since she hates Nathan, she hates Seddie. She is unable to separate the two, even after iCarly ended, she joked about preferring Creddie on reddit.