Talk:Seddie/@comment-3247345-20120409050533/@comment-3247345-20120411033540

If you would rather have Sam's life than Carly's then that's a personal preference that I won't comment on any further since it pretty much speaks for itself. But by over emphasizing the good parts of Sam's life/the bad parts of Carly's (for example relying on exceptions to the rule rather than the rule) and under emphasizing the the good parts of Carly's life/bad parts of Sam's life (for example including Reuben and Gibby to the list of boyfriends when they weren't boyfriends and they are both freaks of nature and not taking into account the bad ending of her 5th grade relationship and the fact that she had to change for Pete) means you're missing out on the clear character roles that Carly and Sam play. No matter who's life you would rather have Carly is meant to be the (almost) perfect character and Sam is meant to be the flawed one who develops over time. Look at how much Sam has changed in both behavior and circumstance compared to Carly. I guess what I'm trying to say is that distorting the picture of the lives Carly and Sam has makes you miss the roles the characters are meant to play, and perhaps even their destinies (within the limits of a Dan Schneider show on Nickelodeon of course). That's actually very important as far as Seddie goes. But each to his own I guess.