Talk:Seddie/@comment-25746087-20141231051536/@comment-25746087-20141231202110

But the question is, @3cooldog92, if it was unforgivable, what was it?

Was Nathan dating Jennette, and then cheated on her with Madisen? First, if that was the case, wouldn't after everything, Jennette would want to have nothing to do with both of them? I know the next part is if that was the case: and then Nathan cheated on Madisen with Carly, and that's why she and Jennette bonded.

I know this theory will be jumped on by those who extremely dislike Nathan: it puts Jennette and Madisen in a good light, and Nathan in the bad light, just as everything should be. But, I'm sorry, I can't believe that if Nathan was dating Jennette at the time, he would actually cheat on her, and I am a billion percent sure Nathan never cheated on Madisen, even though she would like us to believe that.

But you may be right, @3cooldog92, maybe he did do something unforgivable. But, I'm sorry, I just don't see what that unforgivable thing could be.