Talk:Seddie/@comment-4233280-20120430002916/@comment-4184884-20120430013039

I agree actually. Logically, it wouldn't make sense for a girl to date her best friend's ex that was also her first love.

But iCarly isn't big on logic or consistency. If the writers want to make something happen...they will.

It's like, everyone used to say "Oh, Creddie is dead and it will never come back because Sam and Freddie love each other. Dan will never bring it back at all."

Then iOAR happened and people were caught off guard.

Dan's going to do what he wants to do. That said, a lot of people are very fond of Sam and at this point Dan has made it clear that Sam does not like the idea of creddie. With iOAR, he made it clear that the idea actually hurt her. A lot of fans would be incredibly upset to see creddie happen after it's been made clear that Sam is hurt by it (even if the writers suddenly wrote it off as Sam being happy about it. The foundation for her disliking it has already been laid and most viewers that are fond of Sam wouldn't forget that.) Doing something like that runs the risk of running off a handful of viewers, granted it's clear Dan doesn't care about stepping on fans' toes anyways.

Also, there would really be no point in making Sam care in the first place if Dan was just going to change his mind on it later and have her suddenly be okay with it. What would be the point really? Sam has never been positive towards the idea of creddie...since day 1 she's held an ambivilance towards it. I DO think there's a reason for that.

However, iCarly is the sort of show where common logic and consistency just don't always hold true...which is why nothing is ever really certain with this show.