Talk:Creddie/@comment-3541132-20140211054528/@comment-14284535-20140217163919

Well, the Seddiers *are* settling down - reality set in. Because I have given them enough grief about Creddie being canon in the iCarly part of the iCarly-Victorious-Sam&Cat universe, I am going to follow-up here.

> Apparently the Seddiers think it's great that Freddie has gone from being able to say he loves Sam (in a friendship sense)

I have seen this enough here. Prove it. My canonicity rules apply. Nothing from the web page. Nothing from Sam & Cat. Nothing from Dan Schneider's posts. No end titles that were not broadcast. I am looking for a formal proof that would pass muster in a mathematics journal. I have seen nothing that would indicate that he meant that as something other than "the good way." I think you should stop deluding yourselves and accept that Freddie loved Sam.

I am being very fair here - Seddiers HATE it when I ask them to prove that iCarly didn't end Creddie with my rules above, because there is nowhere to go. I am asking you to be just as understanding.

As for that being AU, well, that's up for an other canonicity debate. I left my conclusions on the S&C page for TKTJ.