Talk:Seddie/@comment-3247345-20121221054045/@comment-4184884-20121221141852

Yep. Hypocrisy at it's finest.

And what's even funnier about the whole thing to me is that they have an even weaker case for the goodbye kiss than seddie shippers did with the whole 'I love you' exchange/kiss.

Carly and Freddie said nothing about the kiss then the creator of the show even clarified that the kiss didn't have relationship implications AND provided alternative points of view for what the kiss meant. Meanwhile, Sam & Freddie said 'I love you', kissed, then made out for an hour and a half and the show's creator never felt the need to come out and say that it "didn't have relationship implications" or to provide alternative, non-romantic reasonings to explain the kiss.

Yet, it was "obviously friendly", while it is "completely irefutable" that Carly and Freddie's kiss was a confession of a grand and deep love and that they are obviously together right now.

I should clarify that I do think there was a romantic element to the kiss. They do have a history and I think it was an in the moment sort of thing where, much like Dan said, they both realized how much they were going to miss one another. I think it's very in character for Carly to get really caught up in the moment and to kiss Freddie.

But do I think it was some confession of a life altering love? No.

Do I think they're together? Not at all.

They kissed. That's the only "canon" thing about creddie as of iGoodbye, but it is not canon to say that it was a confession of romantic love or that they are together now.