Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20150226061443/@comment-14284535-20150227001529

@Cc71 - I completely disagree with you. Without exception, the Creddie parents, kids, FF writers, etc. are absolutely convinced that iGoodbye was intended to show that Carly and Freddie are soulmates. They view his fist pumping as showing that any conflict he had over Carly and Sam evaporated when Carly kissed him. Needless to say, those who followed S&C were very confused by #TKTJ.

@Cartoonprincess - They view the comment about Italian boys as being joking because she is clearly saying "I love you" to Freddie specifically when she and Sam get into the lift even though there are two other guys there.

@All - I had to tell several people that I found their pro-Creddie smugness to be very unseemly. I had to explain what I felt the appeal of Seddie was. And wow, did they have their eyes opened when they broached the subject with friends and family who were Seddiers. The people I know toned it down, but still, to them, "Creddie is canon."

For those Creddiers whom I am closest to, I pointed out that the series looked like DS was living out his childhood fantasy in seasons 4-7. They have all since watched the entire series again and largely agree with the sentiment here that DS forcibly split Sam away from Carly and Freddie and that seasons 1-3 were vastly superior and even had some real Seddieness in them.