Talk:Creddie/@comment-4402317-20111012143850

I don't understand how people can think that Freddie wasn't in love with Carly.

That expression on Sam's face (iSD) proves that in that moment that she walked in on Freddie and Carly, dancing, and staring into each other's eyes, that she saw something. She wasn't upset because they were dancing, she was upset because she knew that Freddie's love for Carly had gone far beyond "puppy love" and perhaps Carly actually did have feelings for Freddie. Something Sam wasn't expecting.

Also, in iSY... Freddie stopped Carly from saying that she "loved" him because he knew what love really was, and he knew that even if Carly did love him, that she wasn't in the right state of mind because of the whole "hero" thing.

Freddie might love Sam now, or just for the time, but Carly will always be his first love. :)