Talk:Seddie/@comment-14284535-20140929235251/@comment-3180503-20140930153958

It's amazing how much momentum Seddie had before Season 4. Every single episode seemed to be subtly (and not so subtly) leading up to a Seddie climax that never fully happened. I mean, you could argue that they covered this in the arc but I still believe the arc was poorly done and very out of sync with the first three seasons. At that point, it was a completely different show and the Seddie dynamic was no longer what it was. The arc would have fit better if it was in direct succession with the events of Season 3 and acted as a Season 4 premiere of sorts. By that time, everyone was already fully expecting it so it didn't make sense for them to completely regress to their Season 1 selves like in iSell Penny Tees.

That being said, I have to say @Embargo that Carly did not exactly seem pleased at the thought of Freddie kissing Melanie. She actually seemed quite a bit insecure and jealous--you could see it in her wide-eyed expression. Not sure if that was scripted or not. And we all know how she initially reacted to the Seddie kiss. It wasn't until much later--even after iOMG, I would say--that Carly began to fully accept and support Seddie as a couple. And even then, she still managed to help break them up. :P