Talk:Seddie/@comment-5099474-20120624152246/@comment-4184884-20120624154446

It is about what Freddie wants...but that's really not all it comes down to. It also comes down to what Carly wants and what Sam wants. Freddie has had feelings for both girls and as such, he's really not the deciding factor because we know he has the potential to feel "that way" about both Carly and Sam.

I think the girls are more the deciding factor here frankly and this is where I think whether you ship creddie or seddie really affects your outlook. I think it's safe to say that many seddie shippers do not believe that Carly has "those" feelings for Freddie and that the one time she did, it was hero worship/not her actually liking him "that way."

So, from my perspective at least, unless Dan changes that and makes it clear that Carly is in love with Freddie and is not being influenced by something else (like hero worship) then even if Freddie did want her, what difference would it make if she didn't want him back?

With Sam, it's debatable if she still has feelings for him depending on which side you fall. As a seddie shipper I think iOAR & iPS made it clear she had residual interest, which is the big difference between seddie and creddie for me.

Basically, say Freddie does have feelings for both. In my opinion, I haven't seen anything that points to Carly having those feelings for him, but I have seen things that point to Sam having those feelings for him. So, really I think it's the girls that make the difference.