Talk:Gibby (TV series)/@comment-5192147-20121010164456/@comment-27418159-20170912222910

Maybe maybe not it depends on if gibby could Of done well on his own as a stand alone character because it doesn't seem like separating the main cast of icarly for spin off ideas is working all that well without Carly being involved again. Sam and Cat didn't make it past season 1 because of behind the set issues or whatever caused that one to go downhill. The icarly cast was like family and trying to separate them and have most of them appear once in a blue moon doesn't seem to be working out so well even though I liked sam and cat i think a better spin off idea would be one that actually Involved Carly in it again also the writers still have the whole fan war between seddie and creddie fans to fix which didn't get resolved in Sam and Cat and still isn't getting resolved anywhere else. But honestly there's a lot of unanswered questions that need answering and trying to separate the main cast of icarly who are like family isn't working out so well.