User blog comment:Mak23686/Idea for episode "iKissed him first"/@comment-3144167-20110613233817

Actually, i was reading some pages from old episodes and just remind of Valerie. It's said : "Sam says Freddie never kissed a girl when in reality, he did technically "kiss" Valerie but didn't count it as a true first kiss when talking to Carly, even though it was on the lips. Freddie also mentions that he doesn't think it counts."

So the title would make sense, since Valerie did kissed Freddie first. But the idea of Melanie appearing again is really good! I think it's more probably to happen than to be some Carly X Sam stuff, since Carly seems to be happy for them, and help them on iLMM promo.