User blog comment:Lyrical Saint/Why I don't think iSaved Your life will be resolved/@comment-4402317-20111003063000/@comment-4187547-20111003202136

@GiantKid - Is it your belief that Freddie was lying to Sam, lying to Carly, lying to himself, for the duration of his relationship with Sam?

What evidence is there, in the entire arc, that Freddie was faking feelings? His actions indicate that he was positively smitten, to say the least. How often did he cut Sam from iCarly footage, even at the height of his obsession with Carly? How often did he intentionally exclude Sam from activities with Carly?

Can you honestly say that he was pretending with Sam? That, the entire time, he was thinking he'd rather be with Carly? If so, why did he tell Sam that he loves her at the end of iLY? They had ended their relationship; what did he have to gain, short of the satisfaction of sharing his feelings with her?

Do you think he meant the "I love you" platonically? If you do, then what you're saying is that, while Sam was at her most vulnerable, Freddie entered into a relationship with her with the knowledge that he loved someone else, dragged her along until she, NOT Freddie, suggested ending the relationship and then, knowing she was in love with him, told her he loved her and proceeded to kiss her for an hour and a half, all the while thinking that he loved Carly more.

Does any of that that seem logical to you? Does that seem like something Freddie would do? Is that even the type of guy you'd actually want to be in a relationship with either Sam OR Carly?

You are absolutely entitled to your opinion, and no one's disrespecting that, but it's silly to ignore logic to suit your preferences. If you choose to maintain a positive outlook for Creddie in spite of the evidence against it, that's totally your right, but I have a feeling you're going to be awfully disappointed in the end.