Talk:ICan't Take It/@comment-4305917-20110918182913/@comment-3553219-20110919044043

I sort of agree with @Rosalie. I do think that if Sam said the right thing at that moment he wouldn't have broken up with her. If she said "I love you and I am truly sorry. It was a stupid prank back when I didn't understand my feelings for you.". But Sam was never going to say the right thing right there. Not because she doesn't want to but because she literally doesn't know how. Sam isn't really a person of words or expressing her feelings (which is why she still maintained hating him right up until the point where he kissed her... and look at her now). Carly had to say basically that for her. So, I think Freddie would have broken up and then got back together because really it isn't nearly as bad as other things he has done.

And I don't think what she did was as serious as people say. It wasn't his college application. It was something he really wanted to do and would have helped him for college (I doubt he needs much help, though). And Sam was 110% wrong. But in the course of Freddie's life not going to some sleep away N.E.R.D camp isn't the worst thing in the world. Had she done it to an actual college application that would be worse.