User blog comment:Bolivianbacon/Pinpointing Freddie's Bike Accident/@comment-4184884-20110921013137

Good theory.

Honestly I'm still curious about this. Especially with Carly's "It was four months ago, before she liked you" comment to Freddie about Sam in iCTI. Personally, I think it's rather misguiding. Maybe Carly thinks Sam's feelings are a newer development that happened within the span of four months, but prior actions by Sam (as you've show) prove that's not the case at all.

It's clear in iSpeed Date (at the start of season 3) that she likes him. It's clear in iSYL as well. She's clearly liked him since the start of season 3 at the latest. So yeah, if I had to speculate when the bike thing happened I would guess somewhere around the end of season 2/beggining of season 3.

Four months ago though? Oh Ms. Carly Shay you couldn't be more wrong. ;P

But yeah basically I agree with you. I wish Dan would just give us a definite time though. It'd be nice to have that as opposed to speculations. haha