IDon't Want to Fight

In this episode, Carly gives Sam an iCarly T-shirt to celebrate their anniversary since they met (a flashback scene shows a young Carly and Sam). Sam promises to get Carly tickets to the Cuttlefish concert which has been sold out. While Freddie teased Sam about having pimples on her butt and tries again to strike up a relationship with his crush, Sam trades the T-Shirt for the tickets. This angers Carly and the two girls fight it out so much that iCarly is ruined.

Freddie receives no advice from Spencer, who has been making a fish feeding device for his goldfish. In twist of usual events, Freddie becomes the hero of the day. He controls iCarly by tying the girls' ponytails to ropes and makes them reveal their sides of the story to the iCarly viewers, who get to vote after the show. If either girl interrupts, their ponytail will be yanked. Sam interrupts so much that she is "tortured" by the yanking. However, when Carly interrupts Sam's testimony, Freddie allows it because he loves her thus resulting in both girls yanking each other ropes.

The twist to Freddies' plan was including a third option which stated that both girls were silly and should make up. Sam nearly cries and they hug in time to witness Spencer's fish feeding device. Akin to that of scenes from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, Spencer successfully feeds his fish only to be reminded that he has to rest the device everyday. Carly knows her brother cannot handle pets and take the bowl of goldfish back to the store.