Thread:SeddieBenz/@comment-3247345-20120503034300

Your teacher is correct. The "had" should be in there. The reason I said it isn't necessary is because in America when we use that sentence, we usually don't put the "had" in there, even though we're supposed to. It's just they way we talk to each other. I hope this makes sense.

For your last question, are you asking if you should use a "," or a ";"? Or are you asking if you should use "god" or "dog"? I think you're asking whether you use a "," or a ";" so I'll answer that. The correct way to say it would be "WAIT, I thought you were a dog" If you were asking the other question, tell me and I'll answer that.

Any time you have a grammar question, you can always ask me. 