Talk:Seddie/@comment-24341760-20140302174526/@comment-4196911-20140302181845

He might have. The thing is, you can have two characters kiss goodbye, and it can mean many different things depending on how it's handled. it can seem romantic, or not. If you have dialogue before and after, it can change what you think it means.

The problem here is that Dan had Carly kiss Freddie with absolutely zero context and no dialogue to help explain it. She walks up and kisses him in romantic fashion, bu they say nothing afterward and the scene where Carly is leaving in the elevator they just act like friends. It's almost like Dan just edited in a scene from iSYL right into the middle of iGoodbye with no explanation and no context.

So Dan can claim later that it had no relationship significance (and I agree based on how Freddie's appearance on S&C was handled) but I feel upset on behalf of the Creddiers who are totally within their rights to see that kiss as romantic and not just friendly.

This is what i mean about Dan trying to give something to everybody, and it just got people upset rather than being grateful. It just caused confusion and people weren't sure what to think because he sent mixed messages.