Talk:Creddie/@comment-3277975-20110103074935/@comment-3092491-20110106195443

yes...but the problem is whether or not Miranda and Jennette could portray Sam and Carly's personalities respectively. Maybe Jennette can't get Carly right...maybe Miranda can't get Sam right...personally I'd think this would be true. And then maybe they couldn't interact with Nathan as a couple right...so the whole thing gets turned upside down. The actors are more than just the faces to the personality - they help create the personality.

So, we wouldn't know what Sam/Jennette is like or Carly/Miranda but it's possible that something could feel off to us as viewers. But it's also possible that it couldn't. I just think the girls are perfect in their roles and couldn't really do each other's justice.