Talk:Seddie/@comment-4546225-20120304232643/@comment-3553219-20120305005648

I always thought it would be awesome if they just had her play Melanie! I know some people here don't like her but we actually know very little about her. She isn't a Carly who looks like Sam because Carly would never go after a boy the way she went after Freddie. We don't know that she is always prissy because we barely saw her. Until the very end of the episode we thought that she might be Sam.

I think it would have been an awesome nod to the fans to have her be Melanie and have her be all sweet and nice until Tori brings out her Puckett side. I don't think they would do that though.