Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20150317155145/@comment-3180503-20150317211633

@Turquoise It's not completely shallow in and of itself but if it was the only reason he rejected Jennette (assuming that's how it went down) then that would be absolutely terrible and it would explain a lot of Jennette's contempt towards him (even if holding it against him for this long is still a little extreme). Out of everyone, Jennette and Nathan were clearly the closest and the most compatible (at the time, anyway) so it doesn't make sense that they didn't date--especially since on top of that he seemed really into her.

Since Nathan has shown that his faith is of the utmost importance to him, Jennette's apparent lack of it is the only reason I can think of as to why he would turn her down. I'm praying (heh) to God that I'm wrong but it's the only thing I can make sense of at the moment. And it goes right along with the Nashville theory I posted below.

It sucks that no matter how you look at the Jathan situation, someone winds up looking horrible; whether it be Jennette or Nathan. xP