User blog comment:Cartoonprincess/Why Carly is *NOT* Acting OOC in iLMM/@comment-3213933-20110812021308

Agree 10000000000%!!!! Girl, this is exactly what I've been thinking! You took the words out of my mouth! XD

As much as the Creddiers need to be left alone at this particular time, this blog is really important. I'm really happy you wrote this. I totally agree.

Of course Carly wasn't being OOC. Why in the world would she be? To me, it's a ridiculous idea to even think that. (No offense.)

Another thing is that iSYL was a while back. It was in Season Three and now we're in Season Five (right?). She had plenty of time to get over things and obviously she never really loved Freddie. As we know, he was just bacon. She's gotta be over it by now. There's no doubt about it. All those guys (and probably more, we just didn't see them onscreen) were pretty much the same thing as Freddie. She thought she loved them when she really didn't. It's simple. Why should Freddie be any different?

And about the pain of losing Freddie...I'm sorry, but I think that's really weird. What pain? She only dated him for about a week, how could she feel that bad to spend the next year dating random guys? It just doesn't make sense! She might have loved him before then, but why, may I ask you, did she never go out with him? She could have easily, but she never did.

I'm not saying this is all true. It may or may not be. But it seems pretty likely to me. Carly's a likable person; she's not cruel and she won't ever be. If Carly was cruel, then it would be OOC. Anyways, I doubt Dan would do that. It's not the point of the arc; why should it be there? To cause more drama? I don't think so.

Her freaking out about their first kiss obviously means exactly what you said. They may like each other. Carly's a smart girl; she probably knows that.

Dan is the writer. He may do as he pleases. It's not up to us to decide if the characters are OOC because we are viewers. We don't know as much about the characters as Dan does, so we can't judge. Like you said, if it was iSPT, then we could judge. But this is Dan and this is Dan's show. Enough said. We can't decide if something is "right" or not.

Again, great blog! I truly agree with everything said.

LOL Thanks for reading my rant. Byez!