Talk:Sam & Cat/@comment-2246006-20120806173632/@comment-4559766-20120819194009

I agree. Jennette is one of the most talented members of the iCarly cast and I think it's a huge waste of talent to have her playing the same role. I mean, she played a completely different role to Sam when she guest-starred in Victorious and she was absolutely brilliant in that episode, but here we're just getting more of the same. I like Sam but there's only so much that anyone, even someone as creative as Dan, could do with her character.

In all honesty, I don't mind Cat being on the show because I do like her (albeit nowhere near as much as I did in the first season of Victorious) but the pathetic and immature Ariana worshippers are just going to start argument after argument and that will, to a degree, ruin the show for me. Just like the Creddie vs Seddie fanwar has, to a degree, ruined the direction iCarly was going in. I think Dan had a set plan but the ridiculous arguing has resulted in this irritating Creddie-Seddie rotation and the writers just can't seem to settle for one ship anymore.

Edfan12: Umm why is Trina the stupidest character on Victorious? She might be a bit naive and unaware of her lack of talent but Trina is not stupid. Cat, however, IS a naturally stupid character and has rarely shown any signs of being smart to any degree.

I hate the idea of Sam and Cat running a babysitting business simply because that means that the show will have lots and lots of CHILD ACTORS. Pretty much EVERY child actor who has ever appeared on iCarly or Victorious has been absolutely terrible at acting (I know they are only kids but they have to be able to act to some degree). Plus I find child characters very irritating and I know that this will ruin part of the show for me. And, unfortunately, this sounds like Dan has straight up stolen this idea from Disney Channel's JESSIE. Obviously this show will be like a thousand times better than JESSIE but I can't help acknowledging the fact.

I'll give this show a chance but I've been thinking for a while that it's time I moved on from Nickelodeon, and the fact that iCarly and Victorious (the only two shows keeping me with the network) are ending almost simultaneously is, to me, a sign that the time has come to move on.