Talk:Creddie/@comment-5679407-20121124154101/@comment-5043573-20121124192722

Seth, I think it would be ridiculous for Seddie to continue on in Sam & Cat. Not just because of Creddie but because Sam & Cat should be a fresh start for the characters. While personalities and history should be there, it shouldn't carry the baggage of the last series except for special episodes.

Since Nathan is reluctant to return to Nickelodeon it would be dumb to make Seddie the couple for the series because at best it could result in an off screen break up from something like a text message or a letter or a one sided phone call. Why? Because the most the series will get is that "Seddie canon" with nothing to go to it.

It would be like if Chase and Zoey stayed a couple and then the series continued on without showing Chase and only having a couple mentions of it. You wouldn't want that because it's all name and no substance. Even appearing for a couple of episodes would make this worse.

Now if Nathan agreed to be a somewhat regular character, Seddie happening would be fine. He could appear enough to get some substance but without him it would seriously be blah.

Also, you need to honestly stop saying Carly's character ended with iCarly but keep acting like Freddie's didn't either. As far as we know right now, both Freddie and Carly's characters are done with iCarly with only Sam and Gibby continuing on.

Also, I can honestly say that Sam might still be interested Freddie, but Freddie was only joking about getting back together the same way Sam joked about it in iPear Store. The reason is that he said is very blasé and smug only to backpedal with a "holy crap" look when it seems that Sam might actually want to and changed the subject. If he really did then when she showed interest he wouldn't have backpedaled like he did.

Finally, you mentioned that the Seddie arc was pandering for the Seddies and that he might do it again for Sam & Cat? The thing is, there's a difference between an arc and a series. While Dan knows that Seddie's will want to watch, he also knows that Creddie fans are still fans of Sam and then they could be fans of Cat. He is not going to provide a service to Seddie and alienate half of the previous fanbase just to get Seddies. He's going to provide a service to the fans of Sam, not Seddie and you can be a fan of Sam without prefering Seddie. I think it's extremely arrogant of you Seddies to assume that this series is for you.