Talk:Cibby/@comment-5001566-20121103014907

If Carly does not like Gibby then how come she was the only one that remember he was still in a chimney? Or what about the time she went on a date with him? Gibby even told her 2 times she did not have to go but she went! When Sam beats up Gibby, Carly trys to stop Sam more then when she beats up Freddie. Carly almost ask Gibby to a dance once because she was sad he was not going. I mean come on!!!!