Talk:Seddie/@comment-5679407-20130601050852/@comment-5679407-20130602034048

@Seddierebel2010: I'm not saying that Carly is infallabe, but if you're going to argue that Carly betrayed Sam, in some way, then it has to be shown that as of Carly's kiss with Freddie in iGb, Sam feels betrayed. Because the kiss in and of itself isn't a betrayal. At the time, they were all single and unengaged. Now, if the person who writes for Sam insists that some fans are reading too much into the kiss between Carly and Freddie, then why would Sam read too much into it?

Again, you either embrace Dan's explanation, or you don't. But if you don't, then you can't use that very same explanation to argue against the Creddiers and their perception of the kiss. That would be hypocrisy on both ends. My essential point is that when it comes to how the characters feel--about anything--Dan Schneider is the first and final authority. They are his characters and no one knows how they feel better than he does, just as no one knows how you feel better than you.

We can disagree on how the characters developed throughout the series, and that's fine. But if you're going to put forth that Sam would feel betrayed by her best friend kissing the only boy with whom she's had a serious relationship, I'd have to say that Dan doesn't see it that way. And just as I say to Creddiers who argue that Carly and Freddie are now in love, Dan's context as to how his characters feel-and that includes Sam--is the only thing that matters.