User blog comment:Churchpants/Seddie And Creddie: Both Cliche??/@comment-3015402-20110722043617/@comment-1742110-20110722235357

It fits one of the triangle tropes. yes. But it's not the type of angsty triangle that bothers me. Both girls have not wanted Freddie at the same time as far as we know. If they have it hasnt been made clear yet. They are not in a fight over Freddie. So it's not like....Sam loves Freddie...Carly loves Freddie...And Freddie has to choose.

The closest they have came to that is iQuit iCarly and that wasnt done in a romantic way. Just a friendship way.

Did i have doubts? I would be lying if i said i didnt. Even when it turns out back then the people i trust most in the fandom didnt have doubt at the time of iSYL. I did a little. I guess my point is nothing is wrong with something just cause it's Cliche. It all depends on how the story is told.