Talk:Seddie/@comment-4077450-20110705144233/@comment-1976613-20110705161429

Look it was a good try...but it really wasn't good. It just doesn't make any sense. One, in iSAFW, while Carly, Sam and Freddie said they love all their fans, what they don't like is people who try to force them into relationships with each other, so why would they ask for the Creddie and Seddie fans to help? Also, why would they work with Nevel? Remember at the end of iPTN he is back to being public enemy #1 and he didn't learn anything, so they aren't friends. Third, why would the one girl Freddie gets back with be Valerie, she hasn't spoken to him in three years, he doesn't like her because she used him, so why not just bring in a new character. It's just a rehash of a previous episode. Fourth, it was never established until the last second that he kissed Carly, it came out of nowhere, and fifth why would he just randomly say I love you to Sam, right after kissing both Valerie and Carly? It doesn't work, and sixth Sam wouldn't forgive Freddie in a million years for kissing both girls instead of her no matter how she feels, it isn't part of her character.