Talk:Seddie/@comment-24169317-20150804165659/@comment-25746087-20150804181847

Okay. The story of "the night that Nathan destroyed Jennette's heart by leading her on" is confusing me immensely.

Okay. So, what you had told me @Moden, was when Nathan tweeted that tweet about having to call the police, Jennette's response tweet about "happily tucking away her gun" was in response to the fact Nathan told her that he chose Madisen over her; and that she was so heartbroken, that she wanted to shoot him with a gun and kill him for hurting her. And Nathan hurting her was the reason she cancelled the Ustream.

But there are things that don't make sense. First, what I mentioned, the Ustream was the next night, not the night of these two tweets, but your response, @Moden, was that Jennette was reeling from what happened the night before that she cancelled. But here's another thing. So, did Nathan call the police on Jennette, or did he just call the police about an unknown situation? And if he did call the police on Jennette, what would it be about, since she didn't pull a gun out on him? And if Nathan did call the police on Jennette, why in the world would he tweet about it, even if no one would know who he was talking about? And if he didn't call the police on Jennette, wouldn't that mean that he possibly wasn't even with Jennette then, and that Jennette just saw the tweet and, with her Jennette humor, replied a joke to it?

The "That Night" theory has so many plot holes, and there is 'zero proof. ''I'm sorry @Moden, I don't count your one source who says she knows people who are close to Jennette as total 100% proof. '''I don't, and I can't. And this constant belief that Nathan purposely and knowingly lead Jennette on to believe he liked her is utterly 'ridiculous. 'I'm sorry, but it is.