Talk:Seddie/@comment-14284535-20140507231210/@comment-24341760-20140508000458

First of all itwins is one of the funniest, if not THE funniest, episodes of icarly, ever. (Freddie: "Oh, Twins!  TWINS!!"). But as for your first point, I gotta disagree. I've watched it a million times and I always thought Melanie initiated the kiss with Freddie, coming up from then bottom, and that it looked MUCH more natural than any of the ones during the arc. Also, she makes a point of pulling Freddie closer when they start dancing - it's a very Sam-like aggressive gesture which makes the viewer either believe she is really related to Sam, or unsure whether Sam is, indeed, pretending to have a twin. I don't think they really made out that much, though, because he ran out of the place pretty quickly, and in ITTK he said he only kissed her one time. I think he just meant she had her lips all over his face when she kissed him. Sam says to Melanie "how could you make out with Freddie," but I think she's blowing it out of proportion in her mind. Jealousy, perhaps? After all, it is right after Freddie mentions he kissed Melanie that Sam decides to pretend he's been right all along, and Melanie doesn't actually exist. And, yeah, Durf is stupid, but that's sitcom writing for you.