Talk:Seddie/@comment-4388293-20120409160319/@comment-4988556-20120410002717

I agree with some of those and not others. I totally agree with any instance of her using Freddie's feelings which I think is wrong. And she can be superficial and self-absorbed. Which I like because it keeps her from being too much of a Mary Sue. But I disagree with some fo these.

iPilot- she actually doesn't like the name iCarly and tries to say it wouldn't be fair but Sam was really into it and thought it was a great name (and only wanted to be the sidekick).

iRue the Day & iWant my Website Back- forcing someone to kiss you is 100% wrong (and sexual harrasment) so I am glad she did what she did. It shows real integrity.

iHate Sam's Boyfriend-we don't really know what Carly would have done there. She didn't want to break Sam's heart but she might have figured something else out. I think the fact that she cared so much was sweet.

iCarly Saves TV- Carly tried to stand up for Sam but Sam was thrilled to be fired. She should'nt have to quit (which would be breach of contract and get them in trouble) when Sam wasn't even upset.

iKiss- Carly just isn't a good liar and doesn't think well on her feet. She didn't think to just say Sam was lying because it all happened too fast. And Freddie basically confirmed it by his reaction.

iDate a Bad Boy- Yes she was superficial but she was fourteen and that is completely normal.

iReunite with Missy- She doesn't not believe Sam she has really good reasons to think she was jumping to conclusions. She didn't think Sam was lying about anything. She thought she was making a mistake about the reasons behind it (which is different). Also SAM didn't believe Sam. Sam thought it was all a misunderstanding until Missy flat out said she was right. If Sam thought she might be wrong it is fine that Carly did.

iSpeed Date- She would go with Gibby not Freddie because she didn't want to lead Freddie on. Which is her doing a good thing unlike all of those times she uses his feelings to manipulate him.

iSYL- Physical can be fun and there is nothing wrong with that. She talks to Freddie all of the time why not kiss him if she is in a relationship with him?

iOMG- She had no idea there was a private conversation going on. She didn't know Freddie was going to talk to Sam (he said she didn't send him). She was just looking for Sam to talk to her herself and oversaw what happened. She isn't psychic she didn't know it would be a big deal.

iDS&F- Again she isn't psychic she didn't know it would become a constant thing. She just tried to help and then they abused her good nature.

iCan't Take It- Sam seriously hurt Gibby, they had ruined a couple of iCarly episodes and were ignoring her or putting her in a bad spot. I think she had every right to be upset and then she immediately tried to fix. Literally right away she made everything better. It isn't as though she made it up. Sam really did do that and Freddie really did have a right to know.