Talk:Seddie/@comment-24139638-20150914050530/@comment-24139638-20150914223716

Ehh...I loved Kel growing up, but I couldn't stand his character and just that entire element of the show. Also, I know that over acting is a thing with kids' shows (saw some old iCarly eps recently and some of the early stuff is pretty painful, especially from Nathan), but it was too much for me these days. I think the kids will grow into their roles, especially the girl playing Babe. She's the standout so far in my opinion, but they'll all get more natural with time, so I don't really hold that against the show. Also, there's a character who's very dumb/weird, sort of like a cross between Cat and Gibby, but clearly meant to be cute (the Babe charter comments on his attractiveness a few times), and I just wasn't feeling it. I was never really a fan of the Cat level of dumb and this kid surpasses that.

It's miles above Henry Danger, but I certainly won't be making a habit of tuning in. I know I'm biased because iCarly started when I was a lot younger, but even at its zaniest it managed to still feel grounded (at its peak anyway) and I didn't totally feel that with this show, but it was only one episode, so maybe given time to expand the universe and grow the characters it'll get better.

TLDR: Objectively not awful, but not great either. Given time it could be solid enough for its audience though. Plus it's heavily multi-platfo like iCarly was with the whole app thing. Curious to see numbers.