Talk:Seddie/@comment-3968801-20110618171459/@comment-3553219-20110618181459

I don't think "popular" is always defined as ratings. iTwins is one of those iCarly episodes they play all of the time. Really constantly. So obviously it gets good ratings in repeat viewings. There are some episodes that may have done as well the first time that they hardly ever replay.

I think iTwins and ISYL are the best guesses. For ISYL it would be weird for them *not* to reference it at some point. "Hey remember the time you dated my best friend who you spend most of your childhood in love with" seems like a conversation that has to be had. It could be a "equal" like iThink They Kissed was a sequel, just having them talk about it (which sounds like a terrible episode on paper but iThink They kissed was one of the best).

But I would love if they brought Melanie back for one episode.