User blog comment:Jb1210/Why I'm glad neither Seddie or Creddie happened/@comment-4542190-20121229064124/@comment-4135215-20130111040336

You are correct. Creddie DID happen. In iSYL. It also ENDED in iSYL. Using your logic, I could make just as strong an argument that Cam happened in IGoodbye, as you are making for Creddie happening. It's all just noise, anyway, because, according to Dan, iGoodbye is ship-neutral. Accoridng to him, NONE of the ships happened. He acknowledged them, but that's pretty much it. The kiss at the end of iGoodbye was completely void of context, and thus, doesn;t mean anything,  No meaningful dialogue was spoken, there was no build-up, no resolution. Carly walked in and kissed Freddie, then he fist pumped like a douchebag, which he is. Context? We don't need no stinking context! Honestly, I could make a stronger argument for Cam happening than any you could make for Creddie, because the Cam moment had context, and some emotional weight, two things sorely lacking from the Creddie nod. You said it yourself-- "arguably." Am I a Creddie Hater? No, I can just see the finale for what it is: completely worthless regarding ship resolutions. In iGoodbye, Seddie, Creddie, nor Cam happened. All Dan did was acknowledge each ship's existance, nothing more.