Talk:Seddie/@comment-4764834-20120304031240/@comment-3247345-20120305071926

@MiniRedCupcacke That's what I mean when I say they were stupid to break up. I don't think they gave a good enough reason to break up. Supposedly they broke up because they have nothing in common. That's a load of garbage. They do have things in common. Even if it were true, that seems puny compared to what they overcame during the arc. First Freddie had to convice Sam that he liked her back and to convice her to leave the mental hospital. Then they overcame their fighting problem and learned how to solve their disagreements on their own. Then they survived Mrs. Benson, Gibby, and Carly trying to sabotage their relationship. You can see how much Sam valued their relationship when she beat up Gibby when she found out what he did. Personally I wanted to slap Gibby upside the head for what he did. After overcoming all that, not liking the same things is extremely trivial compared to what their relationship endured. Not to mention the fact that they do have things in common. The reason they focused on their differences is so they could fabricate a cheap resason to break them up. That's one of the main isssues I have with the breakup. Not only did they breakup over somethings stupid, but they contradicted established facts in the process. Like you pointed out, they didn't give a good reason. What I think happened was the writers couldn't think of a good reason to break up Seddie, so they fabricated one, and did a horrible job at making things consistent.