User blog comment:CreddieLuv4eva/Questionable Stuff on the Seddie page (A Biased Rant)-THIS IS FOR CREDDIERS/@comment-3419321-20110421175200/@comment-3419317-20110422054032

@ Seddiegirl98 :

Actually, it would kind of help ... sort of.

In contrast to Sam, Melanie is a minor character, doesn't live in Seattle, and has far fewer fans and supporters. If it was actually Melanie and not Sam who was in love with Freddie, then it would be a much smaller threat to Creddie, because it's a lot easier to get Melanie out of the picture (so to speak) than Sam.

It would be a very weak hope at best, though.

It's all a moot point, anyway, since we can pretty much rest assured that it really was Sam in iOMG. As has been pointed out before, nobody really believes that Sam was actually Melanie in disguise. They were just saying that it might have been a cool or interesting twist if it had been.