Talk:Seddie/@comment-24015721-20140711200158/@comment-14284535-20140713204131

I agree with Cartoonprincess - Freddie's tone is so patronising in iStill Psycho, iOpen a Restaurant, and iPear Store that it borders on the offencive. As Passionate Seddier45 said, I don't know if that would have worked past season 1.

@Seth1028 - Although I could be wrong, 100% disagree with you..

Remember that I always take the easy, obvious interpretation of what is happening in an episode and then try to retcon later. Thus,  if Carly says, "No - I'm glad you do," to "Is it too late for you to love me?" what is the obvious reaction for Freddie? Obviously, to hook up with Carly because he means it.

Therefore, I assume he lied to Sam about his crush on Carly returning, was deliberately being mean and heartless in iStill Psycho, and meant to hurt her on the job in iPear Store. Notice that this interpretation fits what was presented and the obvious alternatives to what was presented on the screen and requires no retconning whatsoever.

Obviously, you don't believe me when I say I am completely neutral when it comes to Seddie versus Creddie. I then made the inference that Creddie was the design based on iPilot, the structure of the series, romance conventions on television, how the romances were handled, etc.

Conversely, take a look at the Creddie page to see how much I defend the Seddiers' viewpoint of the end of "iLove You" because that is the easy, obvious interpretation as well.