Talk:Seddie/@comment-3250643-20110630143834/@comment-3553219-20110630181822

She did overreact. But that's Carly. I totally understand where she is coming from. Carly is the cement in the three friends relationship. Sam and Freddie are technically friends though her. That is less true now but it was true then. I think its important to her that they are both honest with her. When she found out she imagined it as this huge thing they were keeping from her (and it was). And, to be fair, we don't know that she kept the dance from Sam. Just because we never saw them talk doesn't mean they didn't. And its not the same as a kiss. Other than that, she really does tell Sam everything. She had to sneak down and risk getting in trouble to tell Sam about Griffin. I don't think she is a hypocrite. I think she is really open and honest about her feelings and expects the same without understanding that Sam just isn't comfortable with that.

I guess Carly was in the wrong to get that worked up. But no one is perfect. If Sam is allowed to have children laboring in sweat shops and beat people up and, yet have people still love her than Carly should be able to have her flaws too. Sam will always be my favorite but I love Carly.