Talk:Seddie/@comment-14284535-20140929235251

I need an explanation for the end of iTwins.

In the last scene, Freddie says, "You seemed to like my face last night with your *lips* all over them." Putting aside the fact that Melanie thinks Freddie is, "adorable," and, by her own admission, made out with Freddie, there are a few things that puzzle me.

Carly and Sam both know that Freddie thinks that Melanie is Sam. Why don't they ask him why he made out with "Sam"? I just refuse to believe that a boy who "hates" a girl would make out with her just to prove a point.

Is it just me, or does it sound like Carly - though surprised - is actually kind of pleased that Freddie kissed Melanie?

How does it *not* come out in the elevator that Sam kissed Freddie before Melanie did?

And, lastly, Melanie didn't say anything negative about his kissing, how he treated her, etc.. Fine and dandy, but then shouldn't I then infer that that Freddie was pretty nice to "Sam" and stopped treating the date as fake, right? And obviously, we have the answer to Carly's question in iThink They Kissed - if Freddie didn't like the kiss, why did he make out with Melanie?

No wonder you Seddiers go bonkers for these episodes.