Talk:Seddie/@comment-24341760-20140622193602/@comment-24139638-20140622213121

Not a fan of the blind gossip thing. It's a slippery slope and in all honesty, I think the truth tends to lie somewhere in between with these things, but since it's being talked about...

iCarly wasn't cancelled at it's peak. It's ratings had been steadily declining for at least the last season or so. Victorious on the other hand, was at its peak, hence fans' surprise over it being cancelled. That said, neither 2 actors from Victorious or 2 actors from iCarly were "left behind" on the network, so that "they left behind two cast members who were going to turn out just as bad" doesn't fit, unless they're referring to both iCarly and Victorious.

Also, the blind makes it sound like it was a ton of parents complaining about the show, but iCarly's cast was relatively small, so again this sounds more like Victorious who had a much larger ensemble cast. Also, from my understanding, the cast of iCarly was ready to move on (specifically Miranda), so "No wonder the cast kept wanting to shoot the show", doesn't fit iCarly either. I have no idea if this was true of the Victorious cast, as I didn't pay attention to their reactions when the show was cancelled.

The spouting bible verses bit doesn't fit Jennette or Ariana either, unless they're just saying this problem child was paired up with someone in general...in which case it could fit Jennette being "paired up" with Nathan over the course of iCarly for promotional purposes, but then they're also implying that this spouter of bible verses wasn't what he/she seemed either with the whole "producers thought [they] went to church multiple times each week."

Finally, a few months after iCarly finished filming, Jennette said that she was still a virgin, so if you believe her words, she likely wasn't running around having sex all over the place back then, making this a complete non-starter for iCarly.

Anyways, you have to disregard and/or twist a lot of things within this blind item to make it fit for iCarly or Victorious. If anything, it sounds like someone mudled their story and blended the two shows together for a juicier piece of gossip.

Meh.