Talk:Seddie/@comment-3247345-20130106014642/@comment-5679407-20130106190728

@3cooldog92: Yo, don't talk about Carly like that, :). I don't think the kiss between Carly and Freddie makes Carly a bad friend. Carly has always been honest and faithful to her emotions--which is why I don't believe she has secretly been harboring feelings for Freddie all this time as some Creddiers might suggest. Her leaving for Italy that night, I imagine, was very emotional for her, especially after her candid talk with Spencer. Freddie, unlike Spencer and Gibby, is her closest male friend, so her goodbye to him was obviously going to be different. The fact that it manifested in a kiss seems to me as an awkward, "in the moment," thing with a romantic implication. Because there always has been a romantic implication between Carly and Freddie, and Freddie dating Sam never changed that. Will Carly pursue a romantic relationship with Freddie? I doubt it--as Dan, himself, provided context to their kiss.

If anything, the kiss makes Freddie look like a bad friend. Freddie had kissed Carly hours after sheepishly asking Sam if she wanted to get back together with him. And moments after kissing Carly, he throws his arms in the air in an almost "jock-ish" way. Dan has insisted that Freddie had only done this because like any guy he was happy to kiss a nice girl like Carly. Dan also thought this was funny. Despite the implications, I'm not a hypocrite. If we are going to maintain that Dan is the ultimate creator and God of the iCarly universe, then we have to accept his explanation even though it's and obvious pander.

Honestly, I don't really think much less of Freddie. I just think that having him throw his arms in the air was a poor decision. There were other ways to bring levity to the moment. If there's any fault to be had, Dan placed it on Freddie, not Carly.