Talk:Seddie/@comment-4233280-20110904204710/@comment-3553219-20110905021353

He was a jerk to her in iEngrage the Gibby too. And even if it was comedy it still happened. Gibby isn't nice to his girlfriend, he is much less attractive than Carly, he is kind of dumb, he is completely goofy in a way that isn't charming and they don't have any chemistry. Not everyone agrees with all of that and that is fine. But nothing will convince me that Cibby wouldn't be a horrible copout and a disservice to Carly's character. Not to mention really offensive to Creddie fans. Freddie was too nerdy for her but Gibby isn't?