Talk:Seddie/@comment-24015721-20140630205915/@comment-14284535-20140701002611

I have some Seddie stuff that should have been handled better.

1. iOMG - what Sam actually contributes to the project for Freddie and Brad. In fact, just having Brad around would have been better period. I also might have gone with Carly not seeing the kiss.

2. iLost My Mind - I personally would have removed Caleb from the story and have Melanie there to greet Carly, Freddie, and Gibby. Then she can fill everyone in with the back story and then go get their mother. Her bringing Spencer back lends that bit more verisimilitude. Also, I would have focused more on Sam's backstory for liking Freddie.

3. iCan't Take It - At the end: I would have preferred Sam to have a legitimate reason for sabotaging Freddie's application. (I like her feeling her courage increasing to ask Freddie out beforehand, but she saw the girls at NERD camp as real threats.)  I also would have preferred Spencer preventing Carly from leaving and telling Gibby what a jerk he's being trying to break up Sam and Freddie.

4. iLove You - A better handling of the jail sequence would have been nice. The ham in pants is SOOOOOO STOOOOOOPID.

5. Anything after iLove You  that would be changed so as not to makeFreddie look like a vascillating, two-timing jerk. The best method for the entire fan base would be a ship-neutral ending.

6. An honest appraisal of the flaws of Creddie and the plusses of Seddie spread out over the series would have been nice; the way the series presented Seddie as completely flawed and Creddie as idyllic makes me wretch when I just think about it.

7. iSam's Mom - rather than having that pointless subplot about the robber, how about how Sam's Mom's effects on Sam affect the others more keenly.

8. An acknowledgement that the lack of Sam's presence in iChristmas is part of the reason Freddie gives up on Carly and Carly dates Nevel Papperman should have been done.