Talk:Seddie/@comment-4402317-20121122034016/@comment-4196911-20121122045548

'I don't see Freddie being like "You know you don't love me, go to Italy." because who says that to one of their best friends, especially if it's soley because they know that they really don't love one another?'

No, she's already made the decision to leave. She's packed and almost ready to go. But she's wavering at the point of it because it's such a big change in her life.

Freddie's not convincing her of anything. He's reminding her of something she already knows, deep down - just like the end of iSYL.

To me that sounds like Dan getting Carly out of the way so Seddie can happen, which wouldn't bother me for the Seddie part, but because of what Dan did to Carly's character.

It's got nothing to do with Seddie, other than being the reason that Freddie's not interested. He's not "letting Carly go" because he loves her romantically. He's letting her go because he doesn't - and good friends don't talk each other out of the right decisions.

'? I want a Carly that KNOWs what she wants. '

But everything we've been told about this episode clearly implies that this is a difficult decision for her. Where would be the drama if it wasn't? Carly's emotionally torn. Deliberately so.

If Creddie is to be resolved it's from Carly's end

I think Creddiers hope for this to be true, but I don't think it is. Dan used iOAR to put doubt in the audience's mind about what Freddie was feeling not about what Carly was feeling. The resolution/revelation will be about what's going on in Freddie's mind, not Carly's.