Talk:IGoodbye/@comment-5224716-20121125121200/@comment-4135215-20121126041305

I agree with MagSeddier4e, I really didn't get a feeling of a romantic vibe to that kiss.? I don't really get the sense that it was a "goodbye kiss," it was solely there as a "screw you" to the fans, from Dan.? Earlier, he suggests that Sam & Freddie both secretly want to get back together, just waiting for the other to initiate it, then he has Carly kiss Freddie with extremely ambiguous intent.? It was basically Dan telling the fans that he isn't doing the work to answer that question that we have all been asking for years, instead, he's leaving it open-ended.? I personally never felt Carly ever had real romantic feelings for Freddie, nor do I think she was showing any in iGoodbye,? Personally, after the iOAR, I didn't like Freddie very much, and really, my opnion of him never recovered.? I used? to be a hardcore Seddier (and I will forever love the iOMG storyline, and I don't know that Nickelodeon will ever produce a more beautiful 4 minutes of television than the? elevator scene in iLY--though Spencer and Carly in iGoodbye is pretty close), but now, IMO, Freddie doesn't deaserve Sam OR Carly.? Freddie became a skeezy? tool, and both girls deserve someone better than what Freddie became.? Before Sam & Cat was greenlit, I always expected iCarly to end with Sam and Freddie gettting together (or, back together, as the case would have been), but Sam & Cat, either directly or just in the fans' minds, has changed all that.? Maybe Dan intentionally made Freddie increasingly toolish since the conclusion of iLY so that Sam can start anew on Sam & Cat, without the audience screaming for Freddie, when Freddie ain't coming back.? Only Dan knows for sure.