User blog comment:SeddieKissiOMG/Possible reasons why it could've been Melanie in iOMG/@comment-2242989-20110416135437

Also...

1. If Sam was in juvie, Carly and Freddie would already know about it.

2. Sam and Melanie have different voices, and different personalities. I really don't think it's possible for Melanie to be like Sam because Sam still acted like herself at some point. Being in love changes who you are a little bit!

3. If Sam wa sin juvie, we would've known and Sam is IN LOVE with Freddie while Melanie had just a simple crush on him.

4. I don't think Melanie was trying to be Sam in this episode because Dan said the promos aren't misleading and in one promo, it showed Carly saying to Sam, "You been acting different!"

5. Sam DOESN'T hate wearing stripes. She hates stripes on guys. Dan Schneider said that numerous times in his blogs.

6. She could've been possibly confused and she was eating her ham sandwich!

7. That point is very hypocritical. We don't know what goes on in her head. Sam is IN LOVE with Freddie and you just have to accept that. Dan said that the promos aren't misleading and that Sam's IN LOVE with Freddie and she held her feelings in long enough to kiss him and show it, and express it.

8. Dan may like playing mind games with us, which means WHY he said, "And um, Brad would make the perfect boyfriend for some lucky girl," making us think it was Sam (I didn't believe it, but some people did.) The person she actually loves is Freddie and I don't think Melanie would do the unexpected, considering she isn't even in love with Freddie. Like I said, just a simple crush.

9. Again, another hypocritical point. Sam has hung out with Freddie before when there was no one else! (iGinger Fox, iMeet Fred, etc.) And since when has Sam been hanging out with Freddie, "randomly?" She's been hanging out with him since Season 1! Sure, she wasn't in love, but later on in the seasons, she considered him a friend. Watch the end of iSpeed Date then.

I'm sorry if I come out mean, but I reread these "facts" you have and they are absolutely hypocritical.