User blog comment:GiantKid/How I can see Creddie or Seddie happening after iLY/@comment-4184884-20110928144215

I've been meaning to reply to your comments on my talk page so I figure I'll just reply here.

I think my main issue with this idea is Freddie. I just have a hard time believing that, at this point, he would even agree to date Carly. He knows that Sam is in love with him. She's said as much herself. Freddie knows her and he knows that she doesn't...she's not generally the most affectionate and emotional person unless she's really into someone (I.E.: Him). I feel like it would make Freddie look really scummy to take Carly back (and if it was just because she wanted a boyfriend...well, it'd make her look pretty bad too because she'd basically be using him).

I feel like, had the I love you's not been exchanged, then maybe there would be a chance. But with Sam & Freddie letting each other know that they're in love with one another...I just don't find it so believable. Those i love you's were game changers.