User blog comment:Churchpants/Would You Rather...?/@comment-3211359-20110624111005/@comment-1874176-20110624112245

Either one's fine, as long as the one doing it hits a spot where its over quickly.

I'd prefer being stabbed, though; guns are a coward's choice, you don't have to get close to your target and bring yourself in danger of dying when your target defends themselves.