User blog comment:Cartoonprincess/Creddie vs. Seddie: Which kiss was more meaningful?/@comment-3201004-20101228204133

The Seddie kiss, definitely. Ever noticed that pretty much every time Carly and Freddie kissed, with the exception of the last kiss which I thought was really sweet actually, Carly wanted something from him, or had treated the kisses as a "reward" for him doing something for her. Kiss on the nose: she wanted him to fix Jake's voice, JUST so she could get another guy other than Freddie! How is that right?? Kissing a boy so you could get another? And then the 34 min kiss... Carly was just showing her way of "thanks" for the whole I-Saved-Your-Life thing. And the rest of the kisses were just part of that too.

When Sam and Freddie kissed, though, they both agreed on it, like you mentioned. Plus, they could have waited. They could have waited until they had a serious boyfriend or girlfriend and then had their first kiss with them. Freddie could have even persuaded Carly to kiss him, probably, but he didn't. He kissed SAM. And they both seemed to want to share that moment with each other. Carly just seemed like she wanted to kiss Freddie, well, for the reasons I said above.