User blog comment:Cartoonprincess/Creddie vs. Seddie: Who Would Freddie Be Happier With?/@comment-3092491-20110106051341

Well, building on the points you gave...

(Carly) Girl is nice to you + girls constantly rejects you as more than a friend = Girl suddenly claims she loves you.

(Sam) Girl that is mean to you + is your friend and is nice to you sometimes and when it counts = doesn't reject your offer to be more than friends.

I think all this proves is that Freddie should be very, very confused.