Talk:Seddie/@comment-14284535-20140616155726/@comment-3180503-20140616171919

Yeah, Carly's logic confuses me. She gets mad when her best friends don't tell her they kiss, yet did she ever tell Sam about the slow dance she had with Freddie? I don't think so. Not that she needed to. Although, to her credit, she did tell Sam about the iSYL kiss right away. Freddie, on the other hand, didn't bother to tell Carly about the iOMG kiss. Once again, not that he needed to because she saw the whole thing "with my own two eyes." (That was the only moment throughout the entire arc when Carly seemed jealous, btw.)

As for iTTK, my immediate thought was that she was jealous. Or maybe she felt threatened that Freddie could actually like other girls that aren't her. This is really the first time other than Valerie where this possibility has been opened up. This kind of thing is especially threatening when it's your best friend. I think, maybe, judging by who wrote this, they were trying to set up a love triangle at the start of the season (or, I guess for them it would have been mid-season 2). It made sense within the timeline that the kiss would be addressed and that it would cause dramatic tension between the trio. They follow up on this idea in iQuit iCarly where Carly and Sam are all but fighting over him and Carly insecurely brings up that famous line: "Freddie loves me!" which was a little below the belt if you ask me. Interestingly, this episode was written by Dan himself. was he more on board with the Seddie/Creddie storyline back then and then just decided to abandon it? There wasn't that much Seddie in the episode looking back on it. Only the unscripted Freddie pulling Sam out the window. Anyway, I digress. :P

Basically, I think iTTK was setting up for that infamous shipping plot that was never concluded. For whatever reason, they decided to end it with iSYL even though that hardly felt like a conclusion; especially since it wasn't even really a Creddiam ep that emphasized their friendship first and foremost. xP