User blog comment:VividlyJ/Which do you like better? Seddie or Felanie?/@comment-3205802-20101116003712/@comment-3149624-20101118014223

Well their personalities are different, not always necessarily who they like. Carly is friends with both Sam and Melanie, so they aren't always opposite. I guess it could switch the show to being that Melanie would like Freddie and Sam wouldn't or Sam would love Freddie more than Melanie. The latter of the two would kind of bring the entire plot away from iCarly though. So I'm not exactly sure.