User blog comment:FreddieSeddieI'mReady/Why Sam would not be happy if Seddie broke up and Creddie happened/@comment-1874176-20110822173446/@comment-4061054-20110822175459

Even if it was a mutual decision, it just wouldn't happen. Freddie is Sam's first real relationship. If Sam and Freddie broke up and he got together with Carly, she would wonder if he ever truly got over Carly when he was with her or if their entire relationship was a lie. Every time she sees them together she'd be reminded of that. Even if Sam gets over Freddie, doesn't ean it wouldn't hurt her to see him running back to her best friend.