User blog comment:Cartoonprincess/In My Opinion: Where Things Went Wrong '~'/@comment-1759346-20130113232701/@comment-3180503-20130117203047

In my opinion, Sam and Cat is the laziest idea Dan has ever come up with. Instead of possibly using brand new actors and creating a whole new show based around them, he is reusing not only the same cast but the same characters. Jennette and Ariana are way too talented to be stuck on some kiddie show that forces them to continue their juvenille roles when they are capable of so much more. Plus, the whole babysitting thing is already being done by Jessie and the idea of two girls living together parallels 2 Broke Girls (which I've actually never seen). And honestly, maybe it's the fact that I joined the wiki around the time Season 4 came out, but there hasn't been a single episode since Season 3 that I've fully enjoyed. Just compare episodes like iSaved Your Life, iSpeed Date, iQuit iCarly, iThink They Kissed, iSpace Out, etc. to episodes like iSell Penny Tees, iDo, iStart a Fanwar, and a bunch of other mediocre Season 5 episodes that I can't even remember. Again, in my opinion, Season 3 was outstanding and impossible to top but maybe that was the problem. :/