Talk:Seddie/@comment-3092491-20101003233549/@comment-2246006-20101004221347

@LiSi:

1. Personally, I didn't like iSell Penny-Tees simply because I didn't think it was very funny. "Dark humor" aside, virtually nothing said or done in that episode was even remotely funny to me. Spencer's subplot was the only thing that saved the episode from being a total waste of my time, and even then, it didn't measure up to the usual hilarity that iCarly consistently delivers.

2. I agree that iCarly has had its fair share of dark humor over the years. If I'm being honest with you, I can tell you with absolutely no hesitation that I couldn't care less. The show has used dark (as well as vulgar) humor in the past, and nine times out of ten, the jokes and situations which applied those comedic methods were very funny. For me, it's not so much that dark humor was used; it's more that the instances where it was used was absolutely devoid of anything even remotely comical.

Since it wasn't funny, I took it seriously, and realized that not only was this episode a bit of a failure in the comedy department, but all it did was regress Sam's behavior back three years.

3. I didn't find the knife comment funny, but I didn't find it out-of-character for Freddie either. Although on the surface it seems a bit out-of-character because of Sam and Freddie's recent lack of arguing, I have to say, just because there was a momentary lack of arguing, that doesn't necessarily mean that the two don't annoy each other every once in a while. I didn't view this as neither a regression nor an out-ofcharacter moment, but when I think of it in the context of how Freddie and Sam have acted lately, it's a very weird line/action. So I agree with you; Freddie's line was okay.

4. To all: let's get a grip on ourselves. Seddie is by absolutely no means dead.