Talk:Carly Shay/@comment-4542190-20130528124208/@comment-5115575-20130528180356

1) Carly did seem pretty happy when they kissed and helped them get together. I'm not saying she's a Seddier or anything, but she doesn't seem really against it either. The  Tori Vega thing was just because of Steven, and the iSYL thing - no girl would want to hear her boyfriend saying someone else is more beautiful than her. And about the kiss in iGoodbye - we can never know for sure what that kiss really meant to Carly or Freddie cuz they never talked about it. And I think if Carly really liked Freddie she would tell him right after the kiss and if he did like her back they would get together, but instead Carly didn't say anything. And what was the thing that made Carly decide to move to Italy again? Oh, that's right! Cute Italian boys.

2) Yes, Carly has been a wonderful friend to Sam over the years but I just think that if she had feeling for Freddie (which, again, I doubt) or after she kissed him she should've told Sam about it, cuz after all he is her best friend's ex, and they were in love. True, Carly and Freddie have dated in iSYL but Carly never really had feelings for him. If she did, she would've told him after the whole "hero thing" was over. So, since Carly never really liked Freddie there's nothing wrong with Sam dating him, but Carly knows Sam did have feelings for Freddie, so I just think the least she could do was tell her what happened. But she didn't, and in my opinion that doesn't exactly make her the best best friend on earth.

3) I don't think Carly is selfish, but about Exhibit C - Carly and Freddie would break up anyway cuz as I said above, if Carly had feelings for Freddie she would've said so later. What Sam did could've saved them from a really ugly break up that could their friendship and the web show.