Talk:Seddie/@comment-4505027-20111021234723/@comment-3247345-20111022064538

Everyone makes good points. The whole thing about him saving her life is easily countered by the fact that not only would he have done the same for Sam, but the fact that he did, like you mentioned, in iMust Have Locker 239. The difference is, Sam didn't make a huge deal about it. If she would have acknowledged it, she sure wouldn't have mistaken what she was feeling for love like Carly did. The whole first love thing is a huge load of crap. I've said it a million times before and I'll say it again. That crush he had in the earlier seasons wasn't love. It was more of a creepy obsession. The only girl Freddie's ever fallen in love with is Sam. Last time I checked, if you have only been in love with one person, that would make that person your first love. End of discussion. Why do Creddie shippers continue to use these weak arguments that clearly have no merit and can easily be proven false? Simple. They have nothing left. All the arguments they used to have have been proven obsolete by events in the show. Look at iDate Sam and Freddie. Freddie completely blocked Carly from the shot because he was so focused on Sam. The strongest argument they had was that creepy crush of Freddie's. That died with the end of iLost My Mind at the latest. Most likely it died sometime in season 3. They're going to continue to use those crappy arguments because they have nothing left. To any reasonble observer, it's clear that Creddie won't happen. Creddie's chance has come and gone. The Creddie shippers don't seem to get it though. One day iCarly will end, unfortunately. Carly and Freddie will not be dating. Only then will they get it. They'll bitch and complain, but they won't be able to contest that we were right along. Creddie's ship has sailed, and it will not be endgame.