Talk:Seddie/@comment-4730219-20140516201400/@comment-24341760-20140517134311

Butter sock, you know a Creddier is just gonna tell you they only did TKTJ to boost the ratings for S&C, not to mention that S&C is an alternate universe. BUT- there are plenty of reasons, aside from TKTJ, that Creddie was not endgame, even in igoodbye itself. Most important: WHY HAVE FREDDIE ASK SAM IF SHE WANTS TO GET BACK TOGETHER? Just to make him look like a dick? A Creddier would say he just didn't know Carly was still interested when he asked Sam. BUT the writers would have. So why make Sam look like second prize? And why have Carly talk about all the hot Italian guys she was gonna meet (and that is why she ultimately decided to go), right before she suddenly kisses Freddie? Why write it that way? Just to make both Carly and Freddie look like massive jerks? No, can't be. Creddie was not endgame,the kiss was goodbye. I would MAYBE say that the kiss was because there were possibly some feelings there on Carly's part, or because they had dated in the past and Freddie liked her and she wanted to acknowledge that. But the way they acted after the kiss, NOT TALKING ABOUT IT, NOT DECLARING THEIR LOVE FOR EACH OTHER, but just brushing it off VERY awkwardly and she just leaves? No way. Not endgame. Bad writing.

And, yeah, the dinner plans at the end of TKTJ are totally a date.