User blog comment:XxiOMGxx/"Are you Dan?"....No, I'm just not blind to logic and the creator's intentions/@comment-4402317-20111008222431/@comment-4402317-20111008234153

The blogs are canon though. Freddie wrote a blog that was directly taken from ICTI. It's written by the creators of iCarly.

As for your first argument, the only obstacles that got in the way of their relationship was themselves. Honestly, when were they ever happy that they were together? All it was was arguing, kiss, and make up, and then arguing again. If Dan really wanted to show the audience that they were meant to be together, he wouldn't have shown how incompatible they are. They aren't imperfectly perfect. There is nothing perfect about their relationship. Maybe they helped each other along the way, but as Carly said "it's weird and wrong." They made each other miserable. People's main reactions, besides Seddiers that wooed at every kiss, showed how bad the Seddie relationship was. There was nothing to "aww" about in their relationship. In iDS&F it was how they argued about everything, in ICTI it was how Sam would do anything for her own personal gain, at the expense of someone she cares about, and in ILY it again showed how Sam would sabotage something important to Freddie, and how she would use him for her family's own personal gain. They never even spent time together. Their relationship was a disaster, they knew it, hence the breaking up. Also, the kiss. It was the deal breaker. The "last" kiss you'll ever see from them according to icarly.com. After they said that they loved one another, and kissed, they decided to STILL break up.

Let's not forget that nothing was even established in iQ.

Also, Carly wasn't just jealous at the fact that they didn't tell her they kissed, she was upset that they did kiss. Why would one ask how long the kiss was and if it were fun if they were not jealous? She was jealous, even Dan said she was in his fun facts. :)

She didn't want to mess with her feelings, because she would want to date him under the right circumstances. If she did, Freddie wouldn't have believed her otherwise.

I would wouldn't wager on that, I think Creddie is very possible. ;) Give it time, I've seen Dan's formula before.

@Silverv1

Dan is hitting at something. The title is too ironic. ;) At least, that what Creddiers, and even neutral shippers on tumblr at least think. ;)