Talk:Melanie Puckett/@comment-4308599-20110821101752/@comment-1874176-20110821103231

Ummm .... no; Sam and Melanie may look the same (duh, they are identical twins and played by the same actress....), but personality-wise, Melanie is WAY more like Carly.

What makes Felanie different from Creddie is that Freddie didn't have this long-time crush on Melanie.