User blog comment:Lyrical Saint/Why I don't think iSaved Your life will be resolved/@comment-4402317-20111003063000/@comment-4196911-20111004091958

Carly isn't the type of character who hides her feelings. She's never, ever done that. If she thinks she's interested in a boy, she goes after him without hesitating. That included Freddie in iSYL. Carly tried to use the word "love" with Freddie, but he stopped her before she could say it, because he knew it wasn't true and she wasn't thinking clearly because of the whole "hero" thing: "Nothing's changed. You're still the same Carly, and I'm still the same Freddie. You're not in love with me, you love what I DID.",etc. She implicitly agreed with him after he explains it (the cheek kiss seals it) and she's shown zero interest in him since then. What are we supposed to conclude?

I'm sorry, but people who think Carly has "secret feelings" for Freddie but is hiding them for some reason just don't have a very good understanding of who Carly is and what her personality is like.

Saying Carly subconsciously likes Freddie but doesn't realize it is a different argument that is slightly less far-fetched, but I still don't think it's true.