Talk:Seddie/@comment-5044859-20140516170043/@comment-5044859-20140516200024

@cartoon, I somewhat agree with you. If after iSYL they had continued growing back to possibly Carly and Freddie having feelings for each other still, I wouldn't have been happy, but I would have accepted it, since it showed growth. But here's the thing: the only time I think Creddie was truly 100% was during Season 1 and maybe the beginning of Season 2. After iKiss aired, I think they decided to go back and forth between Seddie and Creddie.

Also, in response to him "losing the Creddie fans" as to the iSYL ratings, I'm about 99.9% sure that not ALL the people who watched iSYL were Creddie fans. Sure, all the Creddie fans tuned in; but the episode DID happen during Season 3, which was kind of the "iCarly Golden Age", and I'm pretty sure even if it was a Creddie episode, Seddiers were still curious to see what would happen, as Dan and others said that iSYL was for BOTH Creddie AND Seddie fans (as to whether Sam would get jealous, if Creddie would stay together, etc). I'm pretty sure if NONE of the Seddiers watched iSYL, and it was just Creddiers and neutrals, the ratings number would be A LOT lower, possibly lower than iOMG. I honestly believe that Creddiers were less likely to watch a Seddie episode than Seddiers were to watch a Creddie episode. Also, iOAR aired with CLEAR Creddie, WHY didn't ratings shoot up, having all the Creddiers come back? And, although Creddiers say Sam and Cat is AU (to justify Creddie and make Seddie impossible), it had the highest ratings, and I'm pretty sure Seddiers were the biggest contributors to the high ratings.

@Passionate makes a very good point. In each of the big Creddie episodes before the Seddie arc (like iSpeed Date and iSYL), it CLEARLY shows that Sam is starting to have feelings for Freddie. After iSYL Carly doesn't show still having feelings for Freddie like Sam did after iLove You until iGoodbye. So, AGAIN, if Creddie was either ALWAYS the game plan and the arc was to "shut us Seddiers up", WHY show that Sam CLEARLY still has feelings for Freddie when after iSYL, NOTHING was shown that Carly still had feelings for Freddie?