Talk:Carly Shay/@comment-4542190-20130528124208/@comment-4542190-20130531203206

I like that Carly having feelings for Freddie is debatable (at best) when Creddiers say so but "Carly never really liked Freddie" is a fact when a Seddier says so. Sorry to break this for you but it doesn't work that way.

Carly got extremely out of character with Freddie admiring Tori Vega..nuff' said. And in iSaved Your Life, the other girl was in fact offering Freddie to spend a weenkend with her alone, Freddie didn't made any comments on her beauty. You mixed it up there. And Carly and Freddie were perfectly fine together in iSaved Your Life until Sam poisoned Freddie's mind. Also, I don't know if you remember, but I do- Freddie deeply regretted breaking up with Carly (he screamed "WHAT DID I DO?"). Carly was obviously sad too. But he didn't regret breaking up with Sam. In fact, he wasn't sad at all. No need to say more on that.

Sure... Because they didn't talk in iGoodbye, Carly caressing his hand and kissing him meant absolutely nothing... Very stable and convincing argument..not. Becasue, for you (Seddiers) of course, a mere, halfhearted at best exchange of "I love you" (before you call me biased and wearing ship goggles, I've personally said "I love you" to a number of girls I've been really close to in real life and meant it in a friendly, platonic way. And each time I let it out much more warmly than Freddie or Sam) pwns iChristmas, a slow, romantic dance Carly and Freddie had, Freddie giving his life for Carly, Freddie insisting on Carly (iOpen a Restaurant), the signs from Carly especially in the last season, iGoodbye and so many more.. Yeah well, it doesn't.

You know there are idioms, proverbs etc Wise words that have common sense in them and apply in everyday's life. One of them happens to be "Actions speak louder than words". And also, as Tifa says



What would it take for you to be convinced? Carly breaking the 4th wall and saying something like: "See? I kissed him so, I love him." maybe? Like when someone crosses the street, he needs to say he did it to get across. When something is easily understood, it is omitted (also a rule in grammar).

Cute Italian boys and not because of her father, really? I won't even bother with that...Plain ridiculous...

And last but not least, Freddie's celebration also meant nothing according to you, right? "Carly just kissed me goodbye, it meant nothing, YOO-HOOOOOOO! Hooraaaaaaay!" or "She will be in Italy, we can't be together." Cough cough Just temporary cough cough. And there aren't ways for them to keep in touch i.e. cell phones, internet etc

P.S. Purple, I know Mr.Schneider's actions were driven mainly by profit, fan wars do good in his job, his mask fell off and such. But still, you can't flatten/delete something like the iGoodbye scene just because "he is a troll."

As for rebel, your hollow bravado doesn't scare me. Take your self-indulgence somewhere else.