User blog comment:Yanks28/Seddie vs. Creddie: A look back on Season 3 "Creddie" episodes/@comment-4041072-20110824202741/@comment-4061054-20110824203318

I agree about iSYL confirming that the creddie relationship wouldn't work, but I'm not blaming carly for her mixed feelings in iSYL. It's only natural that she would consider herself to be in love with Freddie. Her gratitude made her forget that It was still the same Freddie. The same Freddie she had rejected time and again. The same Freddie that she would've rejected in a heartbeat before he saved her life. She didn't use him, she really thought her feelings were real. But they weren't. :)