User blog comment:NoodleBooty/Why I believe Freddie won't break Sam's heart.../@comment-3213933-20110413211914/@comment-3419321-20110416160801

@ Abbstagirl :

Actually, no. Freddie did not break up with Carly because he realized that he didn't want to be with her.

He broke up with Carly because he didn't want to take advantage of her. He was concerned that she wasn't really in love with him, but only thought that she was.

http://danwarp.blogspot.com/2010/01/fun-facts-about-isaved-your-life.html

"Everyone knows how much he wants Carly, or at least how much he thinks he does. And maybe he really does!  Yet, Freddie doesn't take advantage of Carly when (he feels) she's not thinking straight.  That's a gentleman.  Freddie is a great role model for young kids without ever being preachy.  Nathan Kress brings a lot of his own personal class to the character." - Dan Schneider

Yes, Dan Schneider acknowledged that it's possible that Freddie doesn't really want Carly (though he also said it's possible that he does), but Freddie's breaking up with Carly in iSaved Your Life wasn't about that. It was about Freddie's moral character, his concern for Carly's well-being, and his willingness to make a personal sacrifice for her sake.