Talk:Seddie/@comment-4388293-20120219234819/@comment-3247345-20120220050004

It looks like they're willing to destroy the integrity of the characters to make their ship happen. Carly never loved Freddie and Freddie never loved Carly. At one point Freddie had a creepy crush on Carly, before he learned the true meaning of love. And at one point Carly mistaked admiration for love. In both of those cases we're seeing them mistake something that's not love for love.

Freddie's not an a**hole. He wouldn't string Sam along like that if he really loved Carly. If that were the case, he never would have dated Sam.

Now I'll talk about Carly. In particular, I'll talk about the way she acted in iDate Sam and Freddie and iCan't Take It. The Creddie shippers will tell you that she tried to break up Sam and Freddie because she had feelings for Freddie. The real reason she tried to break them up was because she was sick of being dragged into their fights. Was she acting selfish? Sure she was. She also aligned herself with Mrs. Benson and Gibby, who themselves were being selfish. The fact that she stopped Freddie from breaking up with Sam says she doesn't have feelings for Freddie. She put her friends' happiness over her petty self interest. If she wanted to date Freddie, she wouldn't have done that. Trust me, what she did was nothing compared to what she would have done if she actually did want Freddie for herself. If she wanted Freddie for herself,she would have stopped at nothing to get him. She would not have rested until she broke them up. That change of heart she had in iCan't Take It never would have happend if Carly wanted Freddie for herself. If Sam had something Carly wanted, Carly would do everything in her power to take it away from Sam so she could have it for herself, throwing Sam under the bus in the process. That includes Freddie. She would have made efforts to get rid of Sam, she probably would have even made a move on Freddie even when he was dating Sam. But Carly didn't do any of this. The reason why she didn't is simple. She doesn't want Freddie.