Talk:Seddie/@comment-3512889-20120110210138/@comment-3553219-20120111004635

If Carly wanted to date Freddie she could have had him. If she had said Freddie was wrong and she liked him he would have stayed with her (she didn't). If she had gone back to him in 3 weeks and said she thought about it and she wanted to be with him he would have dated her. Sam didn't poison anyone. She told him the truth. Carly admitted it was true. Truth isn't poison.

Freddie is Carly's friend. She didn't want to hurt him. If she had stayed with him even longer and then realized she didn't feel that way it would have hurt him. Sam was being a good friend to both of them.

Also, I agree that Carly absolutely knows. The analogy was Nosby Mosby and bacon. Plus, she talks to Sam about everything so she would have asked about it.