User blog comment:Kittygirl7878/not happy about the iPsycho having a sequel/@comment-3250643-20110625001748/@comment-3276102-20110625160515

@ Slicknickshady :

Carly : So ... You don't want me to be your girlfriend?

Freddie : No, I do, but ... I think we should wait a while. Until I'm out of this cast, and this whole hero thing wears off, and then, if you still want to be my girlfriend, I'd be really psyched about it.

- iSaved Your Life

They didn't just agree to wait until the cast came off. They also agreed to wait until the "hero" thing wore off. As some have argued before, the cast was gone by the next episode, but there was never any clear time by which Carly's emotional state would subside.