Talk:Seddie/@comment-3508470-20121023045809/@comment-4184884-20121023141324

Yeah, creddie shippers don't understand that the circumstances of the situations make all the difference. They want to just apply this general rule of: "Don't date friend's 'exes'", while ignoring the fact that Carly didn't actually like Freddie "that way". It was just hero worship. I know creddie shippers will debate this, but I think it was made very clearly by the fact that, after Freddie's cast came off, Carly did not try to date him again. She went on and dated a whole bunch of guys who WEREN'T Freddie and she flat out said she wasn't in love with him. I don't know how much clearer she can get than that. And on top of that, she didn't care at all that Sam wanted to date Freddie. She was happy for them. She straight up said that she thought it was great that Sam liked Freddie. She didn't care. It was no lose to her. I don't get why they try to make some big point with this when the character did not care.

Sam on the other hand has shown dislike towards creddie since day one. It can be inferred that, even if she put on a happy face about it, deep down she would not be happy about Carly dating Freddie. Plus, she really did have legit feelings for him. She said it herself. She was in love with him.

That's what it comes down to.

Carly didn't really like Freddie, so when Sam dated him, she didn't care. Sam was in love with Freddie and doesn't like creddie, so it'd be much more of a blow to her if Carly dated Freddie than it was the other way around.