Talk:Seddie/@comment-24856071-20140410004922/@comment-14284535-20140411003759

@StarShine82093 - I recall this discussion with you. :-)

Anyway, I agree that the problem has been the Jathaners more than anything. Death threats like those that Madisen got from Jathaners may have turned off everyone associated with iCarly to Seddie. Don't underestimate that. In the days before the internet was big, I got the same treatment from SF fans about not liking ST:TNG when it first came out. (Funny thing is now most everyone agrees with my criticisms from back then.)  I still get dyspeptic every time I see something from it - and it's been almost 27 years. And I didn't get thousands of tweets and such giving me guff.

As for doing her part, I imagine she would. Remember that she was never actively anti-Seddie until the Jathaners went nuts, but she did find doing romantic scenes with him off-putting because she was like a brother to her. I get that as well. Even when you want to try out a romantic relationship with someone after being platonic, you feel kind of gross kissing him/her for a while - and sometimes you never get over it. Actors or not, they are still people.

If she goes back and Dan Schneider writes another Seddie script, she'll do it. However, I will bet dollars to doughnuts that if they do hook up, you may see them hold hands, but not kiss. If I were you and got that, I would just live with it.