Talk:Creddie/@comment-3101374-20120317062821/@comment-3999180-20120317153752

I totally agree! :) there's so much that didn't happen in iSYL because of the time limit! :P i'm not entirely sure why Dan wanted to cram it into one episode, unless he wanted there to be unexplored aspects, so there would be something to come back to. :o a lot of people - Seddiers especially, but a lot of Creddiers, also - think that Creddie was "played out" in that episode. however, it blatantly wasn't, unless Dan's just being an idiot. :P that wasn't a successful play out, because there wasn't enough of a relationship shown to have played it out. they broke up, not because they knew they wouldn't work, and really, if you pay attention to what's going on in the episode, not for any real reason. the "reason" they broke up was because Freddie didn't want to hurt Carly, or use her, if her feelings weren't real. he wanted to give her time. A successful play-out, though, is a mutual break-up with the understanding that they wouldn't work out for some reason. this was never mentioned in the Creddie relationship. yes, they broke up "mutually", but really, Freddie broke up with Carly. we never really heard what Carly's feeling on the whole thing was. she never admitted that she didn't really love him. he broke up with her. he regretted doing it immediately, and she never said what she thought. a lot of people think that the reason they both dated other people after that was that they were over each other. i don't think that's true in the least! i think they buried their feelings, each waiting for the other to bring it up again so that they could get back together. they waited so long that they had successfully buried their feelings, and could actually even date someone else without their feelings toward that person being a lie (don't you dare accuse me with the standard, "so you think Freddie was LYING when he said he LOVED SAM?!" because i've just explained that for like the 500th time and i'm sick of people twisting my words. :P don't give me that chiz). i could seriously go on for about another page and a half, but i shall resist. ahaha :)