Talk:Creddie/@comment-5099474-20120624224405/@comment-4184884-20120625224150

Akirelee: Okay I can at least understand that view point. I don't agree of course, but I understand incredulity far more than I do happieness. That moment was a lot of different things depending on your stance, but happieness was certainly not one of them.

As for my opinion, I actually think Sam's face in iSD and iOAR were very similar. The main difference I see is that there's a more pronounced frown on her face in iOAR than there was in iSD, but regardless, both read as sad to me.



And tossing myself into that other bit of conversation on Sam's motivation for breaking up Carly and Freddie, even as a seddie shipper I agree part of her motivation was jealousy. She obviously liked Freddie by iSD and was aware of those feelings so there's really no way to deny that that impacted her actions. That said, I do think it wasn't a totally selfish act either, because the way Sam saw it (and the way most seddie shippers still see it) Carly's sudden interest in Freddie was simply a result of him saving her life and was not predicated on her genuinely being "in" love with him. Sam knew this and she also knew that eventually Carly was going to break-up with Freddie and he'd likely have been more hurt in the long run. Obviously, this is all debatable, but just trying to explain a bit more the opinion of those who don't think Sam's actions came from a totally, 100% selfish place.