Talk:IOpen a Restaurant/@comment-4456492-20120423153826/@comment-5044165-20120423215332

Very good comment and analysis of the ep. Yes I can see that both shippings are in the debate for all the reasons, but let us look at what really did happend. And I will only go by what is canon, either in the episode, on iCarly.com or on Dans twitter or DanWarp page.

Soo, yes there was Creddie- moments. He (Freddie) asked Carly outright about her loving him, which makes the Creddie- shipping at least one- sided canon (not two- sided as Carly did not respond positively to his questions). Creddie also had a few scenes, as when he tried to hang with Carly on various occasions. So, there is no way denying that there was huge amount of Creddie.

But, as somebodycool said, there was also Seddie. Sam was plain unconfortable with the possibility of Freddie starting to like Carly again. Her look in that scene is canon, she was perhaps not jealous but clearly unconfortable. She also tried to be a much nicer - normal - person than she usually is. And we know that the break- up between Sam and Freddie in part had to do with that. So while Creddie had some more outright canon moments Sedie was addressed by canon.

And let us look at the history of the show, Dan does not drop hints out of nowhere, he addressed Sams crush on Spencer in iToe FatCakes. He returned to the Seddie/Creddie- shipping in the iCarly.com video "You´re in Luck" with Sam asking Freddie who of the girls he thought kissed the best. Meaning that Sam still thought of the Seddie- arc. That was canon.

So when we put it alltogether, iOpen... had both Seddie and Creddie in the plot, and both was canon. What we do have - for the very first time (or at least since iSpeed Date) is the possible love triangle addressed as canon/officiall plot. That would be a first since Sam rejected the thought of Freddie as a boyfriend when he was still in love with Carly (s1 - 3), at mid- season 3 - s4 no one in the trio had feelings towards one another (iSaved had Creddie but it ended on good terms), and in late s4 and early s5 Carly had no objections towards Sam and Freddie as a couple (not counting her brief collaboration with Gibby to get them to break up).