Talk:Creddie/@comment-5679407-20121113050817/@comment-5679407-20121114033638

@GiantKid: I could understand that a romantic pairing with Freddie would serve Carly's development if she didn't go out with him for some superficial reason like he's nerdy, unattractive, or isn't tall enough, etc. But Carly has never (openly) expressed such reservations. She's always told Freddie that she likes him, but not that way. That's been established since the first episode.

If Carly ends up liking Freddie romantically in iGoodbye, that isn't really development on Carly's part, as we don't know enough about the flaws (if any) in her dating habits. It would just be Carly liking Freddie--that's all. I won't deny that it would fulfill Freddie's earliest fantasy, but that doesn't really show anything meaningful about Carly. Maybe that is why they've stayed friends for so long, because Carly may just not be into Freddie, even though there are many reasons why she should be.