Talk:Seddie/@comment-5323453-20130217205229/@comment-6314968-20130219042237

@Godlovesusall

1. Who said anything about rape? You're putting words in her mouth. It's fine if you disagree with @Rosandra's assessment of how Freddie viewed Carly but your sarcastic response is  condescending and shows a lack of respect for anyone's opinion but your own. Not exactly the best way to demand that your and other Creddiers' right to an opinion be respected. Just saying.

2. It's funny how you complain about us Seddiers expressing negative views of Carly/Creddie. The Creddiers aren't exactly innocent as far as Sam/Seddie bashing goes. The hatred for Sam has reached disturbing levels in the past (I recall some particularly   vitriolic  comments about Sam from a particular user (I won't give the name since anyone who knows anything about what happened should know) from back when I used to stalk fansites during and after the Seddie arc.

3. You are mocking  us. You're using sarcasm to mock our opinions.

4. No one is pretending like they don't like Creddie or even that they're not biased in favor of Seddie. You however are acting like you're not biased in favor of Creddie. Everyone is biased by their shipping goggles and you're no exception. Facts and logic should form the basis of rational debate and you accusing us of being biased doesn't make your view any stronger (besides the fact it's just stating the obvious). Is it asking too much for you to accept that Seddie isn't some irrational creation of our imagination? How about you actually respond to what people are saying (if you must come on this page) instead of accusing anyone who disagrees with you of hating Creddie and therefore being unable to form a rational opinion?  This " I, a Seddier said so, thus it is a fact." stuff you're accusing us of sounds more like you. Just replace Seddier with Creddier and that's pretty much what you're doing.

