Talk:Creddie/@comment-3541132-20140211054528/@comment-14284535-20140224155432

Aside: once upon a time, when we responded to a post, it was considered bad form to edit your previous post because it could be perceived as trying to make the original responder look bad. If that is not the case here, please let me know.

Occam's razor: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor

I could easily be deliberately obtuse and say that Sam and Freddie always hanging out together from "iQ" through "iToe Fat Cakes" as them still dating-while-not-dating and say that said interaction was indication of mutually reciprocated Seddie, but that would be disingenuous because this explanation ignores that Miranda Cosgrove was not there for filming a couple of those stories.

But let me take the one incontrovertible instance where Freddie reciprocates, IMHO: he asks Sam if she would like to go back out with him in "iGoodbye." That may be a defencive way of asking her out, but that's what it looks like to me. Godluvsusall has a nice anti-Seddie retcon of this, but Occam's razor causes me to take that at face value. Occam's razor is also why I take the Creddie kiss as romantic, no matter what Dan Schneider wrote. (Seddiers do NOT like it when I say that Dan Schneider lied to them because he was not ready for their firestorm of protest over the ending of iGoodbye.)  And Occam's razor is why I say that "iLove You" meant Freddie loved Sam "the good way."

Simply: if your are going to be smug enough to say, "and they still can't accept that iCarly ended with Creddie becoming canon," then you have to be able to tolerate, "Freddie loved Sam the good way.  Period."

BTW, because Dan knows that Creddiers are not watching "Sam & Cat", he has no incentive to keep Creddie going. If he has another reunion special to end the series and has Miranda Cosgrove and Nathan Kress back, maybe he has a brain cramp and makes Seddie canon. What would you guys do then?