User blog comment:FearlessStatic/Creddie & Rily: 2 BFF Ships Scorned?/@comment-2032682-20110721193804

I don't disagree much with the blog.

I disagree with how iSYL happened and treated Carly and Freddie's feelings, and how the writers broke up them by having Sam sabotage the relationship by planting a theory that might not have been true just even if it came from an extreme moment of self-sacrifice. There is nothing wrong with a feeling changing due to an extreme circumstance, and history is littered with examples of chivalry, and extreme measures and events that prove devotion to a cause or person, and sacrificing/risking your own life is basically the biggest thing anyone can do to prove their feelings. Sam had no right to plant that theory in his head. It wasn't her place. But I digress and that's not your point and not anything to do with you.

Anyway. I've got two 'markers' before I consider the Creddie relationship to be dead and buried and sunk for good. Tainted as you say.

The first is obviously the end of the 4th episode. If Seddie is still happening them that's a big big pointer towards Seddie end-game.

The last marker is the first episode of the last season. If that passes with canon Seddie I'm declaring the chances of Creddie canon to be dead.

If it's come that far, a whole season + more episodes with Seddie and then sunk only 9/8/7 etc episodes before the finale any Creddie 'endgame' would be tainted even if it happened and honestly I'd only care because the endgame wouldn't be Seddie and I'd get the minor satisfaction of having "won".

But it'd just be a complete waste of everything Creddie fans wanted to see with their relationship. Woo hoo. We got end-game with three episodes of Creddie overall. Seddie was together for 20 episodes and got a full circle romance arc. I'm not sure that's anything more than a phyrric victory.