Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20150226061443/@comment-3503487-20150226193317

I don't think iGoodbye and the HIMYM finale are comparable. iCarly wasn't supposed to be a show about shipping - more of some teens growing up and the adventures they have. The finale did provide closure in all aspects except shipping. Although some will argue that they did with Creddie, it hardly was closure as it was just a kiss with no explanation. Also, there was no heavy expectation riding on the end of the show, unlike HIMYM. Everyone had expectations for the HIMYM finale, especially everyone who was invested in the characters and their relationships and waiting for Ted to finally wrap up that story of how he met the mother. And it pretty much just left a sour taste even if you were expecting it to happen. Not to mention the writing in HIMYM is way better in the first place and shouldn't end up crashing and burning in the hole they wrote themselves into xP