Talk:Creddie/@comment-5679407-20121122051557/@comment-5679407-20121123072320

@The sage2600: We have two moments from iSYL and iLove You respectively:

Carly: So you don't want me to be your girlfriend?

Freddie: No, I do. But, I think that we should wait a while. Until I'm out of this cast and this whole hero thing wears off. And then, if you still want to be my girlfriend I'd be really psyched about it.

Carly: Okay.

Freddie: Well I should probably get home so my mom can spray me.

Carly: Well, I'll see you, tomorrow.

Freddie: Yeah. Listen, when we kissed before, I didn't realize that would be our last one--for a while--so I was thinking maybe if you wanted to...

Carly (after kissing Freddie's cheek): Good night, Freddie.

Freddie: What did I do? WHAT DID I DO?!

-

Sam: Yeah, I don't know if you and me really click that way.

Freddie: Yeah, but, maybe one day if you get a little more normal--

Sam: Or you get a little more abnormal... Did we just break up?

Freddie: Feels like it... but it was mutual right?

Sam: Yeah, but I'm still gonna tell people that I dumped your butt, and broke your nerdy little heart.

Freddie: Fair enough.

Sam: Oh, well.

Freddie: I love you.

Sam: I love you, too.

Sam initiates a kiss with Freddie.

Freddie: You know it's only 10:30...

Sam: Wanna break up at midnight?

Freddie: That works.

Sam: Okay.

Sam and Freddie make out in the elevator.

=
So tell me how is what Freddie said to Sam any less open-ended than what Freddie said to Carly? Freddie in both circumstances postpones the resumption of their respective romances under conditions: with Carly the condition is that once he's out of the cast and hero thing wears off, he'd be psyched if Carly still wanted to be his girlfriend. With Sam, his condition is that if one day Sam becomes a little more normal, they'd click. Sam also proposes the condition that if Freddie becomes a little more abnormal, they'd also click. There was no suggestion that Freddie and Sam don't bear romantic feelings for each other, only that they being boyfriend and girlfriend wasn't fitting, at least for the time being. Again, this is no different in tone from what he told Carly in iSYL.

I don't disagree that Creddie needs a resolution. But it won't be on Carly's part. It will be on Freddie. Remember in iOaR, Freddie was the one who questioned whether it was too late for [Carly] to love him. So in tonight's episode, it will be about for whom Freddie ultimately bears romantic feelings. Are you guys saying that it's impossible that it's Sam?