Talk:Creddie/@comment-5679407-20121124154101/@comment-5679407-20121124205254

@The sage2600: You're assuming that I want Seddie in Sam & Cat. I would've preferred a resolution along the lines of "I'm not into you, you're not into me, I love Carly." Again, that would've upset me, but? at least it would've been clear-cut. And you guys are contradicting yourselves. You guys ascribed some greater meaning to what Freddie said in iOaR, yet when Dan puts something similar in iGoodbye, Freddie was just saying it in jest? Are you telling me that he hasn't used iCarly, particularly the three preceding episodes, to sort of spearhead Sam in to a lead character? Why the last scene of Sam on her bike, rather than Carly on the plane? He's been using the second half of season 5, to set up Sam & Cat.

Carly's character is ending because she was the main character of iCarly. Freddie, on the other hand is the tertiary charcter, so bringing him back would work better than bringing back Carly. As I said, until it's confirmed that Nathan isn't going to reprise a recurring or regular cast role in Sam & Cat, then I have no problem admitting that I'm completely wrong.

As for my assuming that Sam & Cat is only for Seddiers, I've never presumed such a thing. Reread my comments: I said that Seddiers are the likely viewers of Sam & Cat. I know Creddiers who love Sam; I also know Creddiers who hate her. Can you name a Seddier who hates Sam? And before I have anything else projected on to me, I'm not saying that the shippers will be the only ones who'll watch Sam & Cat. I'm saying that the phone conversation between Sam and Freddie was a purposeful setup so that he doesn't alienate the Seddiers. Dan is basically stating something along the lines of "if you want to know what happens [for sure] watch Sam & Cat. Do I agree with that set up? Not at all.

Can Dan end Seddie once and for all in Sam & Cat? Yes. I even believe it to be likely. Dan can do whatever he wants. That is the essence of my argument. If you don't believe that he'll use Seddie in Sam & Cat, then we can just agree to disagree. But it doesn't change that he can--which seems lost in many of the comments I read on this page.