Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20140919162724/@comment-24139638-20140920115804

See, the thing I don't get is that all of evidence up until that point suggests that it was a Madisen issue but then Jennette makes a total 180 and begins to befriend Madi;  

That actually makes perfect sense if the rumors are true. Think about it like this.

Nathan and Jennette have a history. Madisen comrs into the picture (jealous and skeptical of Jennette from the start). This drives a wedge between Jennette and Nathan, making Madisen the problem, at first. Eventually, Jennette and Nathan get close again (Aussie KCA's) and start talking about getting together. Nathan says he's going to leave Madisen for Jennette. Either he does, but it's short lived and he goes right back to Madisen or he just never does. Now Nathan is the one that has screwed Jennette over. Jennette holds a grudge towards Nathan and Madisen for a while after that (note that they didn't all start hanging out until late last year), but eventually Jennette lets go of the grudge she'd held towards Madisen and accepts that it wasn't Madisen who had hurt her. It was Nathan, thus the relationship with him remains strained, while she's able to create a friendship with Madisen.

All of that said, I don't think the "jathan thing" is still actively a problem today. I'm sure that whatever happened is water under the bridge now and that they've all moved on, BUT what happened likely changed the dynamic of their relationship in a way that's kept them from ever being able to go back to what they were before.