Talk:Seddie/@comment-5044859-20140817043218/@comment-14284535-20140817053019

@LeahSedandHP, @Cartoonprincess - I am probably going to regret this, but I have to ask: why do you assume Madisen is cause of the problems with Nathan and Jennette (and I presume Jennette hooking up with Paul)? IMHO, the stronger inference is that both Nathan going out with Madisen and Jennette being with Paul are the *results* of a falling out of some sort between Jennette and Nathan; i.e., Jennette and Nathan had their problem first and then Nathan started dating Madisen while Jennette sought solace in Paul. That seems to square with the facts from that time just as well as your current theory, but I think it explains everyone's behaviour now far better.