Talk:Seddie/@comment-3977504-20110701090558/@comment-2011415-20110701110929

The thing is...I even got no idea how it was supposed to work anyways! At some point, Dan had written both the kisses or at least thought about making iSYL. So a kiss while they were dancing - nothing with saving a life, so a "real" kiss - and then the iSaved Your Life kiss? And suddenly her feelings are not real anymore? That wouldn't have worked! Dan had to know that, so why did he decided to make iSYL back then?

The only halfway logical reason I can think of is, I guess, that the main reason for a Creddie kiss in iSD was not Creddie "itself", if he decided to have an episode after this kiss where Carly's feelings for Freddie aren't real. That sounds mean, but we already know that the dance scene in iSD was supposed to make Sam jealous ("most significant event", you know). So what if Sam was supposed to walk in when they were kissing? We don't know what would've happened after an iSD kiss, but who says that it's Carly suddenly having feelings for Freddie? Who says it wasn't supposed to be a "counterproductive" kiss, making Carly realize what she always knew - that she doesn't like Freddie "that way"?

Sounds mean, sounds slightly absurd, but it's the only thing I can come up with having both kisses written and especially with iSaved Your Life still being halfway logical - even if she realized she doesn't like him that way, the life-saving thing still could've changed things. With them having a real, true kiss in iSD, I see no way how iSaved Your Life could've worked "logically".

Unless they wrote iSYL first. But...wait, no, that even would've been less logical...-_-'

Ugh, the whole thing is so confusing, I think it was good that Dan decided to "rewrite" one of the episodes. But he went with the one where the was a chance on a "real" Creddie kiss...O_o