Talk:Seddie/@comment-4388293-20120409160319/@comment-3247345-20120410041610

I'm not crazy about Carly either. I probably don't hate her as much as you, but there are some things that she does I don't like. She's shallow, and at times selfish. The fact that she gets everything she wants in life doesn't improve my opinion of her, especially since Sam doesn't get any of that. I think iCan't Take It shows us a lot about Carly. While she did end up fixing what she did, the fact that she would even think about destroying her best friends' happiness and then carry out that plan because the relationship was inconvenient for her says a lot about her. I don't think she's completely evil, but she does have some very unappealing personality traits.

@Lovely Miracle Most of what you said is correct, but I want to point out something. Sam's upbringing explains most of her bad behavior, if it doesn't entirely justify it. I could go on and on about why Sam acts the way she does, but I'll just say that when Sam acts up, it's more understandable than when Carly acts up, given how everything in life was just handed to Carly. When Sam acts bad, it's fair to say she's a product of her environment. When Carly acts up, she just seems bratty considering her life is almost perfect. Your comment about iCan't Take It makes it seem like was innocent in the whole thing. Considering that Gibby sought to destroy Sam first good relationship, Sam was completely justified in beating him up, especially when you factor in the comedic purpose of that. Frankly, Gibby's lucky he didn't get it worse.