Talk:Seddie/@comment-4184884-20120212220636

There's something I don't get with creddie logic. (No offense meant to creddiers, but I'm honestly confused by this.)

So, most of them say Freddie & Sam only meant that they loved each other as friends at the end of iLove You." They don't see it as a serious, romantic, "in love" exchange, but just an "I love and respect you as friend" sort of thing. (Which in and of itself doesn't make much sense to me since Sam/Freddie then proceeded to make out/what have you for another hour and a half. That's not something you do after you tell someone you only love them as a friend. Anyways, my point is that they don't take it seriously.

But yet, they think creddie is "real" love when all the times Freddie had ever told Carly he loved her or ever made mentions of being "in love with her" it was played off as a joke with a laugh track. Freddie has never had a serious moment where he's told Carly he loved her like he did with Sam in the elevator. It was always just a line put in there to get people to laugh at his little school boy crush. It's never shown as something serious.

So, how can they think Freddie is seriously in love with Carly, though his puppy love for her was never taken seriously, yet think that Freddie only loves Sam as a friend when they had a serious exchange of I love you's, followed by making out or whatever they did for another hour and a half? How does that make any sense? No matter how you read it, Sam and Freddie's "I love you" exchanges were not platonic. I don't see how that situation can be twisted any other way.

I hope this makes sense.