Talk:Creddie/@comment-4184884-20121218150744/@comment-4542190-20121220145741

In our view? Seriously?? Here we go again...

I've said it many times, I'll say it once more. What happened between Carly and Freddie in iGoodbye, is NOT debatable, it's NOT open to interpretation.

Carly came to Freddie, held his hand and kissed him. This was all that was needed for Creddie to be complete-Carly's verification. Because, Freddie's side was pretty much straightforward: he loved, loves and always will love Carly (not that Carly's side was not entirely clear, especially towards the end).

Anyway, I don't intend to pass up as the "random guy who throws hatred towards anyone who questions Creddie as canon", I'll answer you.

What you say actually happening- Freddie mentioning the kiss as non romantic, not meaning something for Carly and Freddie as a couple (which, just can't happen, I have stated some reasons I believe why) would simply come out of nowhere (pretty much like Sam's behavior in iOMG), so to my eyes (and to the eyes of many more) it would be something totally invalid. And as Sockstar so correctly put, it would ruin continuity- Carly being Freddie's world (you don't give your life for everyone) and suddenly "forgetting" about loving her, etc.

Moreover, it would ruin Freddie's upright character, portraying him as someone who just toyed with Carly, playing with her feelings (and there would be no one and nothing to guarantee he wouldn't do the same to Sam).