Talk:Creddie/@comment-5099474-20121119200021

I find it interesting that a common theme among Seddie shippers as to why Carly and Freddie should not be together is how it would make Sam feel. What if Freddie ended up with another girl entirely...would that elicit the same, "you once told a girl you loved her, so now you may never love any other girl ever again," response?

No? So you're just morally opposed to a girl dating a guy her best friend has dated?

Wait. No. That's not it, either, because Sam did that first when she broke Carly and Freddie up in iSYL. I see...it's okay for Sam to be a jerk. Yes, she interfered with two people who were not yet head over heels in love, but they were still together...and she obviously did not do it for anyone's benefit but her own. If you have feelings for your boyfriend (girlfriend) but aren't in love yet, does that make it okay for your best friend to split you up? If Carly had pulled Jonah aside and gave him reasons not to stay with Sam, wouldn't that make her an awful friend?

What about what Freddie wants? Wanting to be with another girl, especially considering the history of Carly and Freddie's relationship, does not make Freddie a jerk. It is obvious that Carly and Freddie will never do anything to hurt Sam. A Creddie ending is synonymous with Sam's included happiness. I promise you, the show will not end up on some weepy, sad note where Sam is left broken hearted. Heck, my scenario for iGoodbye is that Sam takes off for L.A. and tells Carly and Freddie to "take care of eachother." If Sam is written in iGoodbye as accepting of Carly and Freddie going out, that completely alleviates any reason to call Carly a bad friend or Freddie a jerk.