Talk:Seddie/@comment-3503512-20120523022842/@comment-4988556-20120523024624

This is a matter of opinion and we will never agree. Freddie said in Season 3 iSYL that if she thought about it and still liked him they could date again. Seddie didn't happen until the end of Season 4. Carly had all of that time and absolutely nothing holding her back. She is not afraid to take an initiative. SHe knew he was interested. And she did nothing. In my opinion, because she realized he was right and had no feelings for him. So I don't see anything unresolved. If there was something to resolve Carly would have resolved it. She had every chance to. She just didn't feel that way.

In my opinion, you don't go after a boy your best friend dated seriously and was in love with. Not when you had every chance in the world before that. Not when you encouraged them repeatedly to date or kiss when you could have said "look, I like Freddie this makes me uncomfortable". Not when it would hurt your best friend even just a "little bit". Good people don't do that. And Carly is a good person. So I can't imagine them ever having her do something that would ruin her. Especially so close to the end. Especially when, even though people came on this board and attacked me for saying that before, Dan made the same exact point in the recent Victorious. And then tweeted he was also "proud of her".

But I am biased and a Seddie fan. You obviously feel differently. I don't think we could ever convince each other otherwise.