Talk:Seddie/@comment-25836170-20150105002853/@comment-14284535-20150105212733

@Cartoonprincess - assuming that Freddie acts like a normal guy who doesn't idealise somebody for no very good reason (i.e., not DS) and that Sam acts they way she would be expected to off camera rather than how Jennette does on camera, he absolutely positively should believe Sam is better. It should be no contest.

HOWEVER

NO ONE ever discusses this with any of the people in question. So Freddie would never answer the question to either Sam or Carly. But I can't imagine why, in guy talk, he would choose Carly - even given Creddiers' analyses. Maybe eventually Carly passes Sam some time in the future, but within the time frame of the three series, it should not be close.

JMO.