User blog comment:StraightACarlaay/Episodes?/@comment-3419321-20110624055423

At this point, we have no way of knowing what Dan Schneider's views are on iSaved Your Life. It is possible that he considers it "resolved" already (as many fans seem to believe), simply through the fact that Carly and Freddie's romantic feelings for each other were never brought up again.

I think that a lot of people, however, are hoping that this is not the case, because they would consider it very anti-climactic. iSaved Your Life was, to many people, a major development in Carly and Freddie's relationship, and it left quite a lot of viewers anxiously wanting to know if Carly's love for Freddie was genuine, or just hero worship after all.

People have spent the past year and a half waiting to find out the answer to that question, and to now be told that the lack of a resolution actually was the resolution ... In my opinion, it's not a very satisfying ending. Many people (both Creddiers and Seddiers) feel that Carly and Freddie should at least have some closure on this.

Also, a lot of people, including Seddiers, are unhappy with the way that Dan Schneider seems to be completely ignoring the Creddiers now. For Dan Schneider to not consider Carly and Freddie's relationship in iSaved Your Life (which was the Creddiers' one big hurrah, so to speak) to even be worth mentioning again, let alone giving any clear closure to, would seem like yet another blow there.

Anyway ... I can understand why you would view it as hypocritical for people to criticize Dan Schneider both for creating a five-episode Seddie arc and for not creating a sequel to iSaved Your Life.

However, I can also understand their point of view. I think that they feel that Dan Schneider shouldn't have created a five-episode arc devoted to a relationship right after he basically lectured the audience about how iCarly isn't about relationships ... but if he was going to do a Seddie relationship arc, they feel that he should have resolved Carly and Freddie's feelings for each other first, or at least at some point.

And some folks also feel that, after waiting all this time for a resolution, Carly and Freddie's relationship really deserves an episode of its own, rather than just a few lines of dialogue or a short scene.

In short, they feel that Dan Schneider shouldn't have done it, but if he was going to do it, then he should have done it differently. At least, that's what I think ... I don't know if I'm right, or even if I'm explaining it all that well. But that's my feeling on it.