Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20140617170342

Guys, I just remembered reading somewhere that Nathan purportedly had a girlfriend sometime in 2008 or 2009. I read it on some site a long time ago the same time I was reading about Madisen. Now, before you all jump on the "IT HAS TO BE JENNETTE!11" bandwagon, I have to say (once again) that I sincerely doubt that they dated. Or, if they did, they were not very public about it and kept it to themselves (which would be an extremely hard thing to do given the rumors and their stardom). Plus, if we take all this Christian/Mormon garbage into account, then I don't see Jennette ever agreeing to something like that no matter how much she liked him. It's not fair to have her change THAT much just for a guy.

Now, is it at all possible that maybe Nathan also had a girlfriend in 2008/2009 when Season 2/3 was shooting and the Jathan chemistry stayed intact anyway? Did Jennette not care? Did she like her better? Did she even know?

I'm with @Starshine that I basically support any girl Nathan would want to be with provided that she's a nice person and she's NOT Madisen. Yes, yes, I know it's unfair. And I know Madisen isn't some kind of devil incarnate. She has her nice moments. I just think the whole Jathan drifting apart when they were once so close thing is too great a suspicion to ignore. And what I REALLY don't understand is why Jen and Madi would be playing besties now. Damage-control, maybe? Could she really just be okay and completely accepting of the way things happened as they happened? It doesn't matter to her that she and Nathan are no longer the true friends they once were? And why kiss up to Madi if she wants to disassociate herself with Nathan? It's all just WAY too puzzling for my tastes. Jennette acts in mysterious ways, but this has to be one of the biggest mysteries surrpunding her. WTF actually went down between all of them (and more importantly, will there be another upcoming feud)?