Talk:Seddie/@comment-5679407-20140711032308/@comment-5044859-20140711140302

It's incredibly nice to know that I am not the only one with seeing problems with the "Creddie was always the plan." Although, it is definitely a possibility that the writers who supported Seddie were fired after Season 3 (like Cartoon and others believe), I don't know if Dan was a FULL Creddie shipper. I'm not saying he's a Seddie shipper, I'm just thinking if Dan truly believed in Creddie all the way, after iLove You he would show CARLY starting to like Freddie again as well rather than it be one-sided on Freddie's part.

Besides the "aw look at Freddie" in iStill Psycho, I never saw Carly taking ANY interest in Freddie (even when it showed Freddie started liking her again) until iGoodbye after iSaved Your Life. Again, I truly believe Carly NEVER developed real feelings for Freddie, and never will. Every time it seems Carly may like Freddie back, it's after something big happens. iSpeed Date, Carly's date was horrible. I'm pretty sure if Carly had an amazing date, she would have NEVER danced with Freddie, or would have said "we're just friends Freddie." iSaved Your Life FOCUSES on how Carly's love for Freddie isn't real. And the iGoodbye kiss, Carly is leaving to live half way across the world and probably won't see Freddie for a couple of YEARS. I'm pretty sure if Carly's dad was staying in Seattle, she would have NEVER kissed Freddie.

If iEmbargo sees this, I just want to respond to an argument you have for Creddie. You have said "Seddie shows all the negatives about their relationship, Creddie shows all the positive"  How is iSaved Your Life positive? The ENTIRE episode focuses on the fact that Carly isn't in love with FREDDIE, but with the fact he saved her life. How is that positive? Yes, the Seddie arc showed the negative aspects of the Seddie relationship, but it also showed the positive, about how much they care for each other even with all the fighting. I know no matter what, you won't agree, but that's just my thoughts on that.