Talk:Creddie/@comment-3473808-20110506154532/@comment-3473808-20110506235610

@Slicknickshady I guess I should have been less vague when I said I was getting tired of what Seddiers are saying, I meant only SOME Seddiers. I'm not saying all Seddiers are dissing Carly, I'm just saying I dislike how some Seddiers are behaving about this.

About what you said about Carly's feelings not being genuine-we don't know that. That wasn't confirmed in the episode or since-we have no way of knowing if they were real until Carly herself says so. Based on Carly's expression in iOMG, we may find out those feelings WERE genuine. Or they may have never been. But there's no way to know yet.

@Itzxlucy I'm not talking about what's said on the Seddie page, that's Seddie business, just like what happens here is Creddie business. I'm talking about what Seddiers say on other pages, like the iOMG part 2 page, and on blogs like Phenglei Khai's here: http://icarly.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:Phenglei_Kai/Don%27t_get_overconfident,_folks (by the way, this blog should be recommended reading for ALL fans who love their ships). Sure, it's absolutely fine if they say whatever they want to say on the Seddie page. But it doesn;t seem okay for Seddiers to talk bad about Carly, Creddie, Creddie shippers, and the chances of a love triangle happening on other, NON-Seddie pages. THAT'S what's getting OOC. Yes, you can share your opinion, that's what this wiki's for, but it's NOT for saying things like "you Creddiers are fighting a losing battle, it's never going to happen". Okay, so you're happy that your ship is happening, I have no problem with that. But please, do you think you Seddiers can try to be respectful to other shippers and tone it down just a little?

@Lotstar as usual, I agree with YOU on that point. You can't say an episode you hate is meaningless and then turn around and tell those who like it they should be happy with this so-called "meaningless" episode.