Talk:Seddie/@comment-5044859-20140425175113/@comment-14284535-20140425193516

Let me repeat myself from the Creddie page.

1. The age thing is nonsense. Several months elapsed in real time between iOMG and iLost My Mind. What does that do to their age timeline? And shouldn't they be out of high school at the end of iGoodbye anyway? You can't argue continuity on such a flimsy argument. We also have Cat's age being correct relative to iParty With Victorious, right?

2, This is even worse. Even if Sam's hurt look hadn't been show, there is no way (let me repeat: no way) that Sam still doesn't have feelings for Freddie at the end of iCarly. Otherwise, she would reject his offer to go out with him again automatically. Period. (Just as if Freddie hadn't had any feelings for Sam at all, he wouldn't have asked her back out again.)