Talk:Seddie/@comment-24169317-20150804165659/@comment-14284535-20150804212626

Just re-iterating:

Why is it not possible (indeed, given what we actually know of these people) that Nathan AND Jennette did nothing wrong (at least, from their points of view), but he still broke her heart? For instance, we know the religious differences could have got in their way. In fact,...

@GoodbyeYellowBrickRoad - we had an intersting discussion on how Jennette felt about Nathan. My view is that if we choose to read into WNFS, we can infer that the male who breaks up with Sarah is a clear send-up of Nathan Kress. If we assume that the resemblance is deliberate and intended to tell us something, we can infer that, whatever happened between them, it happened at a very difficult time in Jennette's life and, from her point of view, it was really shallow.

Note that, for instance, the less religious person would find the religious differences shallow (especially since their backgrounds are two diffferent types of very modern Protestant Christian), but it is the deepest reason to a very religious person.