Talk:Seddie/@comment-4388293-20120219234819/@comment-4196911-20120220051848

"It looks like they're willing to destroy the integrity of the characters to make their ship happen."

No one group of shippers is to blame - it's just human nature. It could easily happen to us if the shoe was on the other foot and our ship was going badly. This always happens, across many fandoms.

Like the idea that Carly has been supposedly hiding "secret feelings" for Freddie or is "secretly jealous.". We heard that one even back before the FanWar episode. Carly isn't the type of character who would ever do that. When she decides she likes a boy, she just goes after him without hesitating - even Freddie in iSYL. She just went for it. When she feels like there's an issue or conflict with her friends, she wants it discussed and out in the open immediately (iTTK). She hides NOTHING, and never has. She's a talker. The idea that she's feeling something for Freddie but hiding it while she dates all these other guys AND goes out of her way to get S &F together is just ridiculous.

Freddie said he loved Carly, so I took him at his word. I don't get bogged down in "crush vs.love" debates. We can't know that. I do agree that he clearly doesn't love her anymore, and hasn't for a while.