Talk:Seddie/@comment-7885234-20140225215709/@comment-24341760-20140226160637

First of all, even if Sibby happens, that does not lead automatically to Creddie "by inference." Unless you accept the premise that if Sam is with any guy other than Freddie, then that means Freddie is with Carly. That's too big a logical leap for me. There are more than 2 girls in the world for Freddie to choose from, he doesn't have to be with a girl at all, and Carly is still in Italy and is not interested as far as we know. For Creddie to happen, it would have to actually happen, there's no basis for inference based on Sibby alone. It just doesn't logically follow automatically by default. Second, there's no reason to believe Sibby will happen. I'm not saying it can't happen, but there's absolutely not one shred of a plot or character-based reason to believe it will based on what we know so far. The fact that Gibby is on the show is not enough. Not every show is about the shipping. These people don't have to end up with someone. The special seems to just be about Nora and Nevel being evil and Gibby visiting because of that. Why anyone should jump to a Sibby conclusion is beyond me, unless we just want to torture ourselves needlessly.