User blog comment:FreddieSeddieI'mReady/Why Sam would not be happy if Seddie broke up and Creddie happened/@comment-1874176-20110822173446

It depends on HOW Seddie would end, I guess; If Sam and Freddie now dated for a while, came to the conclusion "Hey, we don't work as a couple, let's stop it." and broke up with mutual agreement, I guess Sam could live with Freddie dating Carly.

Now, if Freddie just DUMPED her for Carly, I'd DEFINITELY agree.