Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20141025032721/@comment-24139638-20141026134132

I think he just has a thing for the whole brown hair/brown eyes thing. He's said in the past that he prefers brunettes and I think that's pretty clear. He always used to say Kiera Knightley was his celebrity crush.

Also, to Carly's credit, her and Nathan had a thing before Madisen was even in the picture. So while he may sort of be into her now (subconciously) because she she kind looks like Madisen, there was obviously something there with Carly before he even knew Madisen existed.