User blog comment:XxiOMGxx/"Are you Dan?"....No, I'm just not blind to logic and the creator's intentions/@comment-4402317-20111008222431

Very good blog, but as your rival, I will have to counterpoint some of your theories. I'll do this in order in why I think Seddie could possibly not happen again. ;)

1. You argued that the point of them breaking up wasn't a good point to make. I believe this is the number 1 reason in what is going against them. The fact that they overheard a conversation that wasn't directed towards them, internalized it themselves, and concluded that they didn't fit shows doubt of themselves shows how immature and how unsettled they were in their relationship. I look at the arc differently then other Seddiers do. First, why would Dan make an arch when he could have easily had them transition from iOMG into regular episodes as dating? I believe the arc could have possibly been made to show that Sam and Freddie were not meant to be together. Look at the episodes of the arc. iDS&F, this shows how their chemistry, physically, was the only thing holding them together, ICTI shows that it's not and wouldn't be Carly's, Mrs. Benson, or Gibby's fault for breaking up Sam and Freddie, and in iLY we were shown that the only people standing in each other's way of having a successful relationship was themselves. The conversation in the elevator was basically a period at the end of their relationship for me. "We don't "click", we are "forcing" things, and the only thing that worked between us was that kiss which was "intense" and "fun". To me it was Dan basically saying "Yes, they love one another, but the way I wrote them, they can't work. I wrote Sam to be pushy, and Freddie to be a gentlmen/nerd, I'm not going to change their characters. Sam is never going to become "normal" and Freddie "abnormal". The most important part of the show to Dan is the comedy, a comedy that has Sam's abuse of Freddie to be one of the key dynamics in the show. He isn't going to change their characters.

2. The fact that they are broken up means that Creddie is indeed back in the playing field. Regardless of theories, or assumptions, the fact remains that Sam and Freddie are both single. They might "love" one another, but after coming to the realization that they don't "click", they are now single. They are free to date and to like whomever they like. Yes, Freddie could love Sam now, many people break-up with someone they love, and continue to date till they find someone better for themselves. That's what Sam and Freddie could do. Why can't Carly and Freddie continue to have their relationship grow in the next couple of episodes? Did anyone see Carly's new blog? Freddie asked CARLY to come with him to a "puppy" wedding. Not only did he ask her, but he asked her to be the "maid of honor." He didn't ask Sam, and he didn't just ask Carly to come to give him comic relief. There is till something there, and I can't help but chuckle at the title of the blog "puppy love". It screams metaphor/simile/foreshadowing.

3.The iSYL theory is not a good comparison. You argued that Carly should have realized that during ISYL that she would have finally realized her feelings. I think the fact that she accepted his theory, because she was afraid it was true, was a sign that she DOES have feelings for Freddie. The fact that she wanted to date him under the right circumstances, and Freddie vice versa, shows the audience that they care about one another deeply. They don't want to lead the other person on.

4. Carly has been jealous of Sam and Freddie. iThink they kissed is a pure example of it. Her thoughts and feelings about them kissing weren't ones of happiness. In iFSM she is jealous at the idea that Freddie wouldn't marry her. Carly has been jealous. It is a fact. The fact that she has harbored feelings for Freddie, shown through her jealousy, and still acted her regularly "Carly self" is a good sign that she doesn't even realize that she does have feelings for him. Yes, she disallowed Sam and Freddie to break up in ICTI, it's because she couldn't live with the guilt of having her two best friends break up because of her. She is a good friend. And Sam wasn't exactly jealous at the idea of Carly and Freddie dating. If she really loved Freddie, it wouldn't matter if she didn't think they would last, it would kill her to see them kiss. She was completely fine, and even had her mind on other things in this episode.

But yea, I think that the arc was shown to represent how Seddie might not work, and how maybe no one would end up with Freddie. I also think Creddie is likely to happen, even if it leads to Seddie because Dan is the type of writer that has always confirmed things to this magnitude. I think Carly's new blog is a confirmation that Creddie is not done yet. ;)