Talk:Creddie/@comment-4184884-20120708160626/@comment-4184884-20120708214016

@Godlovesusall: The use of the word poisoned isn't all that subjective. ;P lol But I respect that that's your opinion.

'''Well, this may sound like I hate Sam or something like that, but if that's the case, then it's her problem. If Carly and Freddie are happy together (and it was proven that they are in iSaved Your Life), Sam should stay out of it.'''

I have a hard time getting behind this viewpoint if only because their relationships are all so intertwined because of the close friendship they share as a trio. If one of them doesn't like a relationship between the other two, it just won't work and it can't simply just be the "other person's" problem. Also, the staying out of it thing doesn't work either. Carly may have approved of Sam & Freddie's relationship, but she in no way stayed out of it. She had a massive role in their relationship and because of the trio's dynamic that's just how it works.

'''By the way, it would really be a bad idea if both girls were presented to love Freddie and fight over him. '''

It would. It would be awful...but that's kind of my point.

Dan has already shown that Sam loved Freddie. It's debatable whether she still does, but the fact remains that she did. They've already gone there and that's a hard thing to go back from. That is why the whole situation is so complicated and why seddie shippers have such an issue with creddie happening for real now. Sure, feelings change, but Sam and Freddie have that history now. We've seen them tell eachother "I love you" (and as Sam later insinuates it was meant in the romantic "in love" sense of the word & not the platonic sense.)

Dan can make Sam not care or make her get over it if she does care. Dan can make it clear Sam doesn't love him anymore and that he doesn't love her.

But the fact is, at one point, they did. She loved him & he loved her and for me, if Creddie happens (which again I don't discount) it will be forever tainted for me.