Talk:Creddie/@comment-3276102-20110227181139/@comment-3276102-20110301040439

@ NeveisCheese, Bunnyboo50, and Itzxlucy :

Maybe he does, and maybe he doesn't. That wasn't really my point, though.

A lot of Seddie shippers are treating Freddie's line from "iHave a Question : Weird & Random" sketch as rock-solid, indisputable PROOF that Freddie no longer has a crush on Carly.

Just a day or two ago, several people on the Seddie page were saying things like, "I can't believe the Creddiers are still in denial after hearing about this."

THAT is what I don't understand. In my opinion, Freddie's comment about the beef not only doesn't constitute rock-solid proof ... As I see it, it doesn't constitute evidence of anything at all. Not even a little bit.

We're talking about a video where Sam said, with a perfectly straight face, "Let's say you got a big old jar of ranch dressing. What are you going to do, just flap your wings, like ..." and started making screeching sounds while flapping her arms.

After that, Spencer explained to the audience that plastic boats with rubber bunnies make the "Zoom Zoom Lady" pop a purple bubble with pumpernickel.

The only way you could consider Freddie's "We have the beef" line as actual evidence (of anything) would be take it completely out of all context.

I mean, I could point out that when Spencer told the audience to just ignore the beef hanging in front of them, the three boys (Freddie, Gibby, Spencer) all stared at the beef, while Sam totally ignored it. Does that mean Sam doesn't like meat anymore?

I have stated before that I don't believe it's possible to know, for a certainty, whether Freddie still has feelings for Carly or not. At this point, a pretty good case could be made for either viewpoint. (Personally, I'm about 50/50 on this. I think it could go either way.)

So, when Seddie shippers maintain that Freddie no longer has a crush on Carly ... I am not saying that they don't have any legitimate arguments. I believe they do.

But not this one.