User blog comment:IFangirl/Did Freddie ever really LOVE Carly?/@comment-4077467-20110919043839

I didn't even have to read the blog to know the answer (I DID read it though, and it was great).

Of course he never loved her. He had a crush on her at 11 and probably stopped liking her shortly afterwards. He continued to stalk her/ask her out out of habit :P

He never seemed serious about it and Carly never seemed serious about him. The are friends, nothing more. The Seddie arc confirms it.