Talk:Seddie/@comment-3503512-20120523022842/@comment-3503512-20120523214802

@XxArchnemesisxx, Well, I felt that it was left haning because after Freddie explained his feelings, Carly still said "So...you don't want me to be your girlfriend?". You dont say that if you even agree in the slightest about not loving someone. If she agreed with Freddie she wouldve said "you're right, I don't love you like that", but hse never did, and seemed very confused and even hurt that he broke up with her and he didnt not ask for a "last kiss", he said "I didnt know thatd be our last kiss, and a for a while so" to which Carly smiled and kissed him on the elevator. Also, yeah Carly may not have said anything directly, but neither did Freddie and he still liked her. They just grew up and matured and Carly did get a lot more flirtacious with Freddie. ANd about Sam and Freddie's relationship, they dated what like a few weeks at most? Carly said something along the lines of them making big improvements over last week. So it couldnt have been that long. You can't blame Carly for their breakup, Carly wasnt even speaking to them, they clearly mustve known she was right if it lead them to break up, if they didnt believe it, theyd still be together right now. yeah, you're right, Dan does do things for a reason, which is why he showed Carly's reaction to the Sam and Freddie kiss, because it was basically just like the slow dance with Creddie. Sam was shocked that Carly and Freddie were getting that close, and Carly was definitely shocked that they were kissing when it seemed like just yesterday Freddie still loved her. Also, why would Dan throw the jealousy question in Carly's face in iCTI? Clearly there was a purpose, and her thrown off guard stuttery reponse certainly implied she was and thought they were referring to being jealous of Sam for dating Freddie. You can just tell, and she was quick to get the attention off of her which is why she said Gibby told Mrs. Benson. Plus, it makes absolutely no sense for Sam to be jealous, she just dated him a few episodes ago and she decided they "didnt click, that way".