Talk:Seddie/@comment-3180503-20151021232057/@comment-24139638-20151022022216

I agree that iCarly had its moments where it struck a good balance between drama and comedy, though I'd argue it wasn't until at least season 3 that they reached that point and sporadically through the later seasons. I also disagree that the later seasons were more caricatureish. Season 1 seddie was a prime example of a very over the top, almost caricature like relationship and while I think the writers were able to tone it down at certain points during the series, I still think it was overall more caricature like than Lucaya is.

I definetly think Rucas is a million times better written than creddie. It's clear that Lucas and Riley really like each other so it doesn't have that creepy, desperate element that Creddie did. Rucas feels really genuine, unlike creddie. That said, I do get why people like Lucaya and I have a bit of a soft spot for them. Like I said, they're seddie with less vitriol and physical comedy, so I see the appeal. Sort of a seddie lite.