Talk:Seddie/@comment-5044859-20140425175113

So out of curiosity (and a little bit of stupidity), I checked out the Creddie tag on Tumblr, and there are two big points that Creddiers have been making that kind of piss me off that I would like to ask YOUR opinions on:

1. Sam and Cat is AU, therefore, the Seddie in #TheKillerTunaJump doesn't count and the only thing that does count is iCarly, iGoodbye, and Creddie. You know, I don't think majority of Creddiers adopted this idea until the announcement of #TheKillerTunaJump, in worry that Seddie may happen, so they made up the "Sam and Cat is AU" to justify that Seddie has no chance, and even if it did happen in the special, it doesn't count. I'm pretty sure that last shot in iGoodbye where Sam rides off is to show CONTINUATION to Sam and Cat, where Sam also mentions in the S&C pilot "my best friend moved to Italy." They use the excuse "in iCarly, Sam should be 19, and in S&C she's 16." Did they ever say Sam was 16 in S&C, and even if they did, SO MANY shows have discontinuity in time. In the episode iGot a Hot Room, Carly's birthday is supposed to be in July, but there's a scene that they're in school, so, that doesn't make sense, but it still happened.

2. iOpen A Restaurant showed that Sam was letting Freddie go, because she knew Carly and Freddie were meant to be. OKAY. I saw this on the Creddie tag on Tumblr, and it was actually posted by a member of this wikia, and like, I don't understand. Yes, Freddie absolutely started crushing on Carly again, but how in the WORLD can you say that Sam realized Creddie is "meant to be" and that she was happy for them?!?! LOOK AT HER FACE. They zoom in on Sam's face after Freddie literally confirms his crush for Carly again, and, sorry Creddiers, she looks pretty UPSET. I know the Creddiers believe that when Sam said, "well go", she meant, "go get your girl Benson, I understand that you and Carly were always meant to be and I'm happy for you." But I'm sorry, even if I was a neutral fan, I would have interpreted when Sam said "well go", "get out of my sight Benson, I may cry or punch you in the face and I really don't want you to see me get upset over you."

So I'm sure you guys probably COMPLETELY disagree with these statements as I do, as Seddie fans, but I really want to know what you guys think.