User blog comment:IFangirl/Did Freddie ever really LOVE Carly?/@comment-4097189-20110919200914

Nahhh, he used to be a little obsessed with her and what not, but not love :P He was only a little preteen when this started anyway. I think he stopped liking her even before he started liking Sam (Or maybe even at the same time).

When you think about it, if he really loved her iSYL he would have been more eager to kiss her like he did Sam in iLMM but it was always her pulling him and never the other way around^^